Remember my first time sipping bourbon neat? Wowza – felt like swallowing a campfire. That’s when I started digging into what to mix with bourbon. Turns out, mixing isn’t cheating; it’s unlocking flavors. Whether you’ve got a $15 bottle or a fancy small-batch, this guide covers everything from classic combos to weird-but-wonderful experiments. Let’s crack this open.
Why Mixers Matter for Bourbon
I used to think purists had it right – until I tried Buffalo Trace with ginger ale at a BBQ. Game changer. Bourbon’s vanilla and caramel notes play well with others, unlike some stubborn scotches. Mixing solves common headaches:
- Budget bottles shine (no need to waste Pappy on Coke)
- Tames the heat for new drinkers
- Creates seasonal twists – try apple cider in fall!
Honestly? My go-to Thursday night pour is Evan Williams with soda water. Fight me.
The Classic Bourbon Mixers (Tried & True)
These combos survived Prohibition for a reason. They just work.
Cola & Bourbon: The Heavyweight Champ
My Basic Recipe: 2 oz mid-shelf bourbon (Four Roses Yellow Label works great) + 4 oz cola + squeeze of lime. Build over ice in a tall glass.
Coke dominates, but I prefer Mexican Coke – real sugar mellows the burn. Pepsi? Too sweet for me. Pro tip: Skip diet soda. The aftertaste clashes with bourbon’s oakiness.
Ginger Beer: The Spicy Soulmate
Bourbon’s warmth + ginger’s zing = magic. Use strong, dry ginger beer like Fever-Tree or Q Mixers. Bland versions (looking at you, Schweppes) drown in sweetness.
| Bourbon Type | Ginger Beer Pairing | Why It Works |
|---|---|---|
| High-Rye (Bulleit) | Spicy ginger (Blenheim #5) | Pepper notes amplify spice |
| Wheated (Maker's Mark) | Mild ginger (Fever-Tree) | Caramel melts into sweetness |
Unexpected Bourbon Mixers That Actually Work
Got skeptical when my buddy mixed bourbon with pickle juice. Surprisingly refreshing! Here’s weirder stuff I’ve tested:
Cold Brew Coffee
Skip sugary Kahlua. Try:
2 oz bourbon + 3 oz cold brew + 0.5 oz maple syrup. Shake hard with ice. Heaven for night owls. Works best with nutty bourbons (Jim Beam Black).
Apple Cider
Fall in a glass:
Warm mug of cider + 1.5 oz bourbon + cinnamon stick. Cheap bourbon shines here – no need for top shelf.
My Disaster Story: Tried mixing bourbon with grapefruit juice last summer. Bitter trainwreck. Stick to orange or pineapple juice.
Seasonal Mixers for Bourbon
Your bottle shouldn’t gather dust between Thanksgiving and Derby Day. Here’s my year-round rotation:
| Season | Mixer | Bourbon Type | Proportion |
|---|---|---|---|
| Spring | Lemonade + mint | High-corn (Evan Williams) | 1:2 bourbon to lemonade |
| Summer | Iced tea + peach syrup | Balanced (Wild Turkey 101) | 1.5 oz : 4 oz tea |
| Fall | Hot apple cider | Wheated (Larceny) | 1.5 oz per 8 oz cider |
| Winter | Hot chocolate | Bonded (Old Grand-Dad) | 1 oz per 6 oz cocoa |
Cocktail Mixers Beyond Basics
When you're feeling fancy but lazy:
Old Fashioned Shortcut
Skip muddling sugar cubes:
2 oz bourbon + 1 tsp maple syrup + 2 dashes Angostura bitters. Stir with ice. Orange peel garnish.
Bourbon Sour Hack
No fresh lemons? Use 1.5 oz bourbon + 1 oz lemon juice concentrate + 0.75 oz simple syrup. Shake like crazy.
Bourbon Mixer FAQs (Real Questions I Get)
Is club soda a good mixer for bourbon?
Surprisingly yes – especially with high-proof bourbons like Knob Creek. The bubbles lift flavors without sweetness. Add lemon twist.
Can I use diet soda with bourbon?
I avoid it. Aspartame clashes with bourbon’s vanilla notes. If cutting sugar, try soda water + dash of bitters.
What’s the worst mixer for bourbon?
In my experiments? Grapefruit juice. Turns everything bitter. Milk curdles – bad idea. Tomato juice? Just... no.
Equipment & Pro Tips
Don’t overcomplicate:
- Ice matters: Big cubes melt slower. Crushed ice waters down drinks fast.
- Glassware: Use highballs for tall drinks, rocks glasses for stiff pours.
- Tools: A $12 Boston shaker does everything. No need for fancy gadgets.
Final Thoughts: Play Around!
After testing hundreds of combos, here’s truth: there’s no wrong answer to what to mix with bourbon. My weirdest success? Basil Hayden’s with coconut water. Tasted like tropical vacation. Experiment with what’s in your fridge right now. Worst case? You pour it out and try again. That’s the joy of figuring out what to mix with bourbon – endless possibilities without breaking the bank.
Comment