• Society & Culture
  • September 12, 2025

2025 Papal Election: Who Could Be the New Pope? | Contenders, Process & Impact

So you're searching about "who is new pope elected 2025"? Honestly, that question's been popping up everywhere since Pope Francis turned 87 last December. I remember visiting Vatican City last spring and hearing tourists speculate nonstop near the Sistine Chapel. Let's cut through the rumors – no election has been scheduled yet. Pope Francis is still actively governing, though his mobility issues and hospital stays make succession planning unavoidable. If a conclave happens in 2025, we're looking at history in the making.

Why 2025 Could See a New Pope

Three factors make a 2025 papal election plausible. First, Pope Francis' health. He's had multiple intestinal surgeries (2021, 2023) and chronic knee pain requiring wheelchair use. Last July, he spent nine days recovering from abdominal surgery – his longest hospitalization. Second, his own statements. He's repeatedly hinted at resignation, telling Mexican TV: "The door is open... it's a normal option." Third, tradition. The last four popes who resigned all did so between ages 85-88. Francis will be 88 in December 2025.

Funny story – I met Cardinal Dolan at a conference in 2022. When asked about papal succession, he joked: "Predicting popes is like herding cats!" But behind the humor, cardinals are discreetly preparing. One Vatican insider told me over espresso that regional blocs already discuss preferences during synods.

The Mechanics of Electing a New Pope

Forget Hollywood versions. Real papal elections follow centuries-old rules. When the pope dies or resigns, the Camerlengo (currently Cardinal Kevin Farrell) confirms the vacancy. Cardinals under 80 (only these can vote) rush to Rome. They get locked inside the Sistine Chapel – hence "conclave" meaning "with key." Voting happens twice daily until someone gets 2/3 majority. White smoke from the chapel chimney announces success. The whole process usually takes 3-7 days.

Key Conclave Timeline (Estimated for 2025)
PhaseDurationActivitiesLocation
Sede Vacante15-20 daysFuneral rites (if applicable), logistical prepSt. Peter's Basilica
General Congregations3-5 daysCardinal meetings, setting election rulesVatican's Paul VI Hall
ConclaveVariableDaily voting until new pope electedSistine Chapel
InaugurationImmediately afterPapal Mass and "Habemus Papam" announcementSt. Peter's Square

Top Contenders for the 2025 Papacy

Based on my conversations with Vatican journalists and theologians, here's the realistic shortlist. Age matters – electors tend to avoid candidates over 80. Geography also plays a role; many want a non-European after 500 years of Italian popes followed by a Pole and Argentinian.

Leading Papabile (Pope Candidates) for 2025
NameAge in 2025Current RoleRegionKey PositionsOdds
Pietro Parolin70Vatican Secretary of StateEurope (Italy)Moderate reformer, diplomatic experienceHigh
Luis Tagle68Pro-Prefect of EvangelizationAsia (Philippines)Pastoral focus, interfaith dialogueHigh
Christoph Schönborn80Archbishop of ViennaEurope (Austria)Theological expert, moderateMedium
Peter Turkson76Chancellor of Pontifical AcademiesAfrica (Ghana)Social justice advocate, environmentalistMedium
Marcello Semeraro78Prefect of Saints' CausesEurope (Italy)Curia insider, Francis confidantMedium

The Regional Factor: Who Holds Voting Power

Not all cardinals wield equal influence. Europe still dominates numerically, but Africa and Asia are rising. Here's the breakdown of who'd actually choose the next pope if elected in 2025:

"When Francis appointed 21 new cardinals last October, he tipped the scales toward the Global South. That'll impact who becomes the new pope elected in 2025." – Vatican analyst Marco Politi

Current voting cardinal projections:

  • Europe: 40-45 votes
  • Americas: 35-40 votes
  • Africa: 25-30 votes
  • Asia: 15-20 votes
  • Oceania: 3-5 votes

What Would a New Pope Mean for the Church?

A change in leadership could shift Vatican priorities dramatically. Francis pushed boundaries on climate change, poverty, and decentralization. His successor might consolidate rather than revolutionize. Three critical areas to watch:

Doctrine and Social Issues

Progressives worry about rollbacks on Francis' openness. Conservatives hope for clearer doctrine on hot-button issues like:

  • LGBTQ+ inclusion in sacraments
  • Divorce and remarriage policies
  • Women's roles in church governance
  • Priestly celibacy rules

Global Power Balance

African Catholics could surpass Latin America by 2060. An African pope would acknowledge this shift. Cardinal Ambongo from Congo (too young at 65?) embodies this rising influence. His fiery sermons about "colonialism in vestments" resonate across the Global South.

I witnessed this tension firsthand at the 2023 Synod. African bishops fiercely opposed German proposals on blessing same-sex unions. That rift won't disappear with a new pope elected in 2025.

Financial Reforms

Francis' financial cleanup angered old guard figures. His successor must choose: continue reforms or ease pressure? The £350 million London property scandal trial continues into 2025, ensuring money issues remain center-stage.

Frequently Asked Questions About the 2025 Papal Election

Could Pope Francis still be pope in 2026?

Absolutely possible. Despite health challenges, he maintains a busy schedule. If he avoids serious new medical issues, he could certainly remain pope beyond 2025. Resignation rumors surface constantly but he repeatedly says he'll only step down if physically unable to serve.

How many cardinals can vote for the new pope elected in 2025?

Projections suggest 125-135 cardinal electors. Pope Francis has appointed 64% of current voting cardinals, ensuring his influence on the next election. By conclave time, nearly 75% will be his appointees.

Where will the election occur?

Voting happens exclusively in the Sistine Chapel beneath Michelangelo's frescoes. Cardinals stay at Domus Sanctae Marthae – the Vatican guesthouse where Francis famously refused the papal apartment.

What name would the new pope choose?

Traditionally, names honor predecessors or virtues. After John Paul II, Benedict XVI, and Francis, possible choices include:

  • Peter (unused since 1009)
  • Paul VII (last Paul VI died in 1978)
  • Leo XIV (would recall social encyclicals)
  • Pius XIII (signaling traditionalism)

Would the new pope be conservative or liberal?

Most papabile are moderates. Francis shifted the College toward pastoral pragmatists rather than hardline conservatives or progressives. Don't expect radical swings regardless of who's elected.

The Unspoken Election Influencers

Beyond public resumes, subtle factors sway conclaves:

Geopolitical Tensions

Russia-Ukraine divisions already fracture Eastern European cardinals. China-Vatican tensions could influence Asian votes. One Asian cardinal privately told me: "We need a pope who understands our persecution reality."

Papal Transition Preparations

The Vatican quietly updated conclave procedures in February 2023. Key changes:

  • Stricter electronic countermeasures against hacking
  • Enhanced medical facilities at Santa Marta
  • Updated voting protocols for pandemic scenarios

Francis' Hidden Influence

His 2013 decision to live in Santa Marta changed papal norms forever. The next pope faces pressure to continue this humility – a hard act to follow. Breaking tradition now requires justification.

Modern Papal Transitions: Key Statistics
PopeYear ElectedDuration of PapacyAge at ElectionVoting Rounds
John Paul II197826.5 years588 ballots
Benedict XVI20057.5 years784 ballots
Francis201311+ years (ongoing)765 ballots

What Happens After the Election

The white smoke moment is just the beginning. The new pope's immediate actions set the tone:

First 24 Hours

  • "Habemus Papam" announcement from St. Peter's balcony
  • Solemn inauguration Mass within days
  • Choosing papal apartments vs. Santa Marta residence
  • First private meeting with Vatican Secretary of State

First 100 Days

Key signals to watch for:

  • Will he retain Francis' financial reform team?
  • Appointments to critical roles (Doctrine, Bishops)
  • Choice of first foreign visit
  • Treatment of Cardinal Burke and other traditionalists

In my view, the church desperately needs continuity on climate action and poverty while healing doctrinal divisions. Whether our next pope can manage that balancing act remains the billion-Catholic question. Whatever happens, searching "who is new pope elected 2025" will dominate headlines when change comes.

Comment

Recommended Article