You know that moment when you grab an egg from the fridge and wonder if it's still good? Yeah, it happens to me all the time. Especially since I tend to buy eggs in bulk. So here's what I do: I drop them in water. You've probably heard the saying that bad eggs float or sink, right? But is it really that simple? Let's crack this mystery together.
Why Does This Float Test Even Work?
Why would bad eggs float while good eggs sink? It's all about what's happening inside the shell. Eggs aren't airtight. They have teeny tiny pores. As an egg gets older, two things change:
- Air sneaks in through the shell over time
- The liquid inside evaporates bit by bit
Think about what happens when you leave a glass of water out. It slowly disappears, right? Same thing happens inside an egg. The moisture content decreases, and air replaces it. That air pocket at the wide end of the egg? It grows as the egg ages.
Now, fresh eggs are dense. Really dense. Almost like little rocks. That's why they sink straight to the bottom in water. But older eggs? They've got more air inside. And air is lighter than water. So when that air pocket gets big enough, the egg becomes buoyant. That's when it floats.
I tested this once with eggs I knew were expired. Three floated right to the top. But one sank! When I cracked it open though... wow. Bad smell. Made me realize this test isn't foolproof.
The Science in Plain English
Density rules here. Fresh eggs have higher density than water, so they sink. Bad eggs develop lower density due to air buildup, making them float. It's not about the egg being "rotten" yet, but about aging.
Performing the Float Test: Step-by-Step
Here's how I do the egg float test at home:
- Fill a bowl or container deep enough to cover an egg with about 4 inches of cold water
- Gently place eggs in the water one by one
- Observe what happens immediately
Now, what do the results mean?
| Egg Position | What It Means | What You Should Do |
|---|---|---|
| Lays flat on bottom | Very fresh (1-2 weeks old) | Perfect for poaching or frying |
| Stands upright on bottom | Older but still safe (2-4 weeks) | Great for hard-boiling or baking |
| Floats near surface | Likely spoiled or very old | Discard immediately |
Hot tip: Use room temperature water for most accurate results. Cold water can mask buoyancy slightly.
Why Some Bad Eggs Don't Float
Here's something most guides won't tell you. Last month, I had this egg that sank vertically but smelled like sulfur when I cracked it. Turns out, if bacteria invade but don't produce much gas, the egg stays dense. So it sinks even when rotten.
This is why you should NEVER taste raw eggs to check freshness. Salmonella is no joke.
Beyond Floating: 5 Other Ways to Spot Bad Eggs
Since the float test isn't perfect, here's what else I do:
The Sniff Test
Give it a good whiff right after cracking. Fresh eggs have almost no smell. Bad eggs? You'll know immediately. Rotten eggs produce hydrogen sulfide - that infamous "rotten egg" smell.
Crack and Inspect
Examine the contents:
- Yolk: Should be dome-shaped and vibrant yellow/orange. Flat or broken yolks indicate age
- Egg white: Fresh whites are thick and gel-like. Watery whites mean old eggs
- Color: Pink, green, or iridescent hues mean bacteria. Toss immediately
The Shake Test
Hold the egg to your ear and shake gently. No sound? Probably fresh. Sloshing noise? The white has thinned - sign of an older egg.
Candle Method
Shine a bright flashlight through the egg in a dark room. Look for:
- Cloudy egg white (good sign!)
- Large air cell (over 1/8 inch suggests age)
- Dark spots or blood rings (indicating spoilage)
Shell Inspection
Check for cracks, sliminess, or powdery residue (mold). Any of these mean toss it.
Storing Eggs Right: Make Them Last Longer
Want fewer bad eggs floating around? Storage matters. Here's what works for me:
| Storage Method | Temperature | Humidity | Max Shelf Life |
|---|---|---|---|
| Refrigerator (main shelf) | 40°F (4°C) | 70-80% | 4-5 weeks |
| Refrigerator (door) | 45-50°F (7-10°C) | Varies | 2-3 weeks (not recommended) |
| Countertop | Room temp | Uncontrolled | 1-2 weeks max |
Important notes:
- Always store eggs pointy-end down - keeps yolk centered
- Never wash eggs before storage - removes protective bloom
- Keep eggs in original carton - prevents odor absorption
I learned the hard way not to store eggs in the door. Temperature fluctuations from opening the fridge ruined a whole dozen. Now I keep them on the middle shelf.
Your Egg Questions Answered
Can you eat eggs that float vertically?
Maybe, but be cautious. Semi-buoyant eggs are usually safe if cooked thoroughly, but I wouldn't use them for raw preparations. Crack them into a separate bowl first to check smell and appearance.
Why do store-bought eggs last longer than farm-fresh?
Commercial eggs are washed and coated with mineral oil, sealing pores. Farm eggs retain their natural protective coating but absorb fridge odors faster. Trade-offs either way.
Do fertilized eggs spoil faster?
Not if refrigerated promptly. The float test works the same regardless. Fertilized eggs just have a white spot on the yolk (the blastodisc) - not a spoilage indicator.
Can freezing prevent eggs from going bad?
Yes, but not in shells! Crack them into containers first. Frozen yolks get gummy though - better for baking than scrambling.
How accurate is the bad eggs float or sink method?
I'd say 85-90% reliable for detecting spoiled eggs. It's great for spotting old eggs but less perfect for identifying early bacterial contamination. Combine with other tests.
Egg Freshness Timeline: What to Expect
Based on USDA data and my own fridge experiments:
| Age of Egg | Float Test Result | Best Uses | Safety Status |
|---|---|---|---|
| 0-7 days | Sinks horizontally | Poached, fried, soft-boiled | Safe |
| 1-2 weeks | Sinks vertically | Scrambled, omelets | Safe |
| 3-4 weeks | Tips upward | Baking, hard-boiled | Cook thoroughly |
| 5+ weeks | Floats completely | None | Discard |
Interesting fact: Eggs are usually 3-6 weeks old when you buy them! That "sell by" date is typically 30 days after packing.
When to Ignore the Float Test
Some exceptions to the bad eggs float or sink rule:
- Refrigerated farm eggs: Might float if freshly laid due to natural air pockets
- Porous shells: Some breeds (like Leghorns) have thinner shells that admit more air
- Altitude effects: Water density changes at high elevations - adjust expectations
When in doubt, throw it out. One bad egg can ruin a whole recipe.
Cooking with Older Eggs: Smart Tips
Those semi-floating eggs aren't useless! Here's how I use them:
- Hard-boiled eggs: Older eggs peel easier because the air pocket separates the membrane
- Meringues: Thin egg whites whip better for fluffy peaks
- Baking: Perfect for cakes and cookies where texture matters less
- Deviled eggs: Mix yolks with mayo and mustard - masks any texture issues
Just avoid using older eggs for:
- Sunny-side-up eggs (won't hold shape)
- Hollandaise sauce (may not emulsify properly)
- Soufflés (won't achieve maximum rise)
Final Reality Check
So, do bad eggs float or sink? Mostly float. But here's my take after years in the kitchen: The float test is your first line of defense, not your only one. Combine it with smell and visual checks. Store eggs properly to minimize spoilage. And trust your instincts - if something seems off, skip it.
Last week I caught a sinking egg that smelled foul. Saved my carbonara from disaster. Made me glad I don't rely solely on the float method.
Remember, food safety isn't worth gambling on. That cheap egg isn't worth a hospital visit. Stay safe and happy cooking!
Comment