Man, thinking about the Nintendo DS takes me straight back to high school. I'd sneak my cobalt blue DS Lite during study hall, trying not to get caught by Mrs. Jenkins while grinding Pokémon levels. That clamshell design and touchscreen felt like pure magic back in 2006. But here's the thing - even today, the DS library holds up shockingly well. Let's cut through the nostalgia fog and talk real talk about the actual best titles worth hunting down.
Why the DS Library Still Matters Today
You might wonder why bother with a discontinued system. Honestly? Two reasons: First, these games were built for quick sessions - perfect for commutes or waiting rooms. Second, the dual-screen setup created gameplay you literally can't replicate anywhere else. Remember blowing into the mic to extinguish flames in Phantom Hourglass? Good luck doing that on Switch.
Prices are climbing though. Last month I saw a sealed copy of HeartGold sell for $250 on eBay. Makes me wish I'd kept my childhood copies instead of trading them for pizza money.
The Definitive Top Nintendo DS Games Rankings
After replaying 50+ titles over the last year (yeah, it became pandemic project), here's my authentic take. These aren't just critic darlings - they're the games we actually kept playing:
| Game Title | Year | Genre | Avg Price Used | Why It's Essential | My Rating |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| The World Ends With You | 2008 | Action RPG | $45-60 | Revolutionary combat using both screens simultaneously | 10/10 |
| Pokémon HeartGold/SoulSilver | 2010 | RPG | $80-120 | Best Pokémon remake ever with following Pokémon | 9.5/10 |
| Chrono Trigger DS | 2008 | RPG | $55-75 | Definitive version of the SNES classic | 9.5/10 |
| Ghost Trick: Phantom Detective | 2010 | Puzzle Adventure | $65-90 | Mind-bending puzzle mechanics | 9/10 |
| Advance Wars: Dual Strike | 2005 | Strategy | $30-45 | Perfect turn-based tactical gameplay | 9/10 |
| Castlevania: Dawn of Sorrow | 2005 | Metroidvania | $40-60 | Best DS Castlevania with touchscreen magic seals | 8.5/10 |
| Elite Beat Agents | 2006 | Rhythm | $25-40 | Most absurd rhythm game ever made | 8.5/10 |
What Holds Up Surprisingly Well
- Pixel art games like Shantae still look fantastic
- Local multiplayer (Mario Kart DS still slaps)
- Stylus controls in games like Trauma Center
What Feels Dated Now
- Early 3D graphics (looking at you, Mario 64 DS)
- Forced touch controls in some ports
- Friend codes - thank god this died
Hidden Gems You Probably Missed
Everyone knows about New Super Mario Bros, but these under-the-radar titles deserve attention:
Rocket Slime
This tank battle game had no business being this good. You play as a blue slime launching yourself into enemy tanks. Sounds ridiculous? It is - and completely charming. Found my copy at a garage sale for $5 - steal of the century.
Hotel Dusk: Room 215
Hold your DS sideways like a book in this noir mystery. The sketchy art style feels like watching pencil drawings come alive. Word of warning: the pacing is slower than Sunday traffic.
Contra 4
Pure old-school pain. This thing will kick your butt six ways to Sunday. Played this with my nephew last month - he rage quit after 20 minutes. Some things never change.
Top Nintendo DS Games by Genre
RPG Masterpieces
The DS was an JRPG powerhouse. Square Enix alone released over 20 titles. Here's what still holds up:
- Radiant Historia: Time-branching story ($70-100)
- Dragon Quest IX: Best co-op RPG on DS ($35-50)
- Mario & Luigi: Bowser's Inside Story: Funniest RPG ever ($25-40)
Puzzle Games That'll Fry Your Brain
| Game | Unique Mechanic | Difficulty | Price Range |
|---|---|---|---|
| Professor Layton series | Brain teasers + adventure | Medium/Hard | $20-35 each |
| Picross 3D | 3D sculpting with numbers | Easy to learn/Hard to master | $15-25 |
| Meteos | Vertical block matching | Intense | $10-20 |
Smart Buying Guide for DS Games in 2023
Hunting for DS games now is like treasure hunting - with more fakes. Here's what I've learned:
Price Check Reality
- Pokémon games always expensive (blame collectors)
- Atlus titles shoot up after going out of print
- Common sports games: $3-5 at used stores
Spotting Fake Cartridges
Bought what I thought was Platinum version last month. Fake. How to avoid my mistake:
- Real cartridges have deep black plastic
- Authentic labels are matte, not glossy
- Font on back should be crisp
Where to Actually Find Deals
- Local game stores: Better for inspecting cartridges
- eBay auctions: Set alerts for "DS lot"
- Facebook Marketplace: Best for bundles
Pro tip: Japanese imports are cheaper for non-language dependent games like Rhythm Heaven
Frequently Asked Questions About Top Nintendo DS Games
Q: What's the rarest DS game?
A: Power Punch without question. Boxing game with Mike Tyson? Yep. Saw one sell for $2,500 sealed. Even loose copies fetch $800. My white whale.
Q: Can I play DS games on newer systems?
A: Officially? Only original DS/3DS models. Nintendo Switch has zero backwards compatibility. Unofficially, homebrew solutions exist but require original hardware.
Q: Are DS games still being made?
A: Production ended globally in 2014. Final western release was Big Hero 6 if you're curious. Kinda sad ending for such a legendary system.
Q: Which Pokemon game is the best on DS?
A: HeartGold/SoulSilver hands down. The walking Pokémon mechanic hasn't been topped since. Platinum has better post-game though.
Personal Regrets and Final Thoughts
Wish I'd treated my original DS better. That hinge crack still haunts me. But the games? They're timeless.
The beauty of top Nintendo DS games is how experimental they were. Where else would you get a game about being a lawyer (Phoenix Wright) next to a brain surgery sim (Trauma Center)? This system took risks modern consoles won't.
My advice? Grab a DS Lite (best model) and start with The World Ends With You. Then try something weird like Electroplankton. These top Nintendo DS games deserve more than landfill obscurity.
What's your DS white whale? Mine's still a complete copy of Solatorobo. Maybe next paycheck...
Comment