So you're heading to Montauk? Good choice. Let's talk about food because honestly, finding great restaurants in Montauk can make or break your trip. I've spent summers out here for years, and I still remember my first disappointing meal at this overhyped seafood spot near the pier. But don't worry - I've eaten my way through this town so you don't have to make those mistakes.
Montauk's restaurant scene? It's wild. You've got everything from $5 fish tacos at a surf shack to white-tablecloth dinners where the check might make your eyes water. The trick is knowing where to go for what. That's why I put together this no-nonsense guide covering every type of dining spot you might need during your Montauk stay.
Seafood Spots That Actually Serve Fresh Fish
Let's get real - when you're looking for restaurants in Montauk, fresh seafood should be priority one. But not every place actually delivers. Here's what's worth your money:
The Clam Bar
41 South Elmwood Ave • (631) 668-4241 • Open daily 11:30AM-9PM (seasonal)
Must order: Montauk Pearl Oysters ($24/dozen) and the Lobster BLT ($29). Don't even think about skipping their Key Lime Pie.
What I like: They shuck oysters right at the entrance so you know they're fresh. Last August, I watched them unload crates from the dock across the street.
What bugs me: Cash only! Found that out the hard way with a hungry group. ATM fees are brutal here.
Duryea's Lobster Deck
65 Tuthill Road • (631) 668-2410 • Opens 11:30AM, closes at sunset
Pricey but worth it: Whole lobster goes for $38 market price, lobster roll is $34
Pro tip: Come for sunset drinks even if you don't eat dinner here. That view over Fort Pond Bay? Unreal.
Personal take: Their lobster bisque has ruined all other bisques for me. Creamy without being gloppy, perfect balance.
Local insight: Ask where the fish came from. Real Montauk restaurants will proudly tell you which boat brought it in that morning. If they hesitate? Big red flag.
Breakfast and Brunch That Won't Waste Your Morning
Nothing worse than wasting vacation hours waiting in line for mediocre eggs. These breakfast spots get it right:
Joni's
51 South Erie Ave • No phone, no reservations • 7AM-2PM daily
What to order: Breakfast burrito ($14) or acai bowl ($12)
Vibe: Surfboards on walls, reggae music, everyone's in flip-flops
My go-to: Cold brew with oat milk. They use local beans roasted in Sag Harbor.
Montauk Bake Shoppe
76 Main Street • (631) 668-2435 • 6AM-4PM
Don't miss: Blueberry crumb cake ($6/slice) and ham & cheese croissants ($5.50)
Warning: Get there before 10AM if you want any pastries. They sell out fast.
Confession: I've driven 20 minutes just for their chocolate chip cookies. Worth it.
My worst Montauk meal: That fancy brunch spot on Ocean Ave with the $18 avocado toast? Dry bread, mushy avocado, service slower than a hibernating bear. Learned my lesson - stick to the locals' favorites.
Dinner With Actual Atmosphere
Some evenings you want more than just food - you want an experience. These dinner spots deliver:
Scarpetta Beach
Sunset Highway • (631) 668-6000 • Dinner starts 5PM
Reservations: Absolutely required (book 3 weeks ahead in summer)
Signature dish: $46 spaghetti with tomato basil sauce sounds simple? Best I've ever had.
Price reality: Expect $150+ per person with drinks and tip
Honest opinion: Overpriced? Maybe. But watching sunset from their deck while eating truffle pasta? Priceless.
Navy Beach
16 Navy Road • (631) 668-6868 • Opens 5PM
Don't leave without: Grilled octopus appetizer ($19) and striped bass ($38)
Cool factor: Tables right on the sand, fire pits for chilly nights
Good to know: Parking situation is terrible. Take a cab or Uber unless you arrive early.
Comparing Montauk's Top Dinner Spots
| Restaurant | Avg Dinner Cost | Reservation Needed | Best For | Kid Friendly? |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Scarpetta Beach | $$$$ | Essential | Romantic dinners | No |
| Navy Beach | $$$ | Highly recommended | Groups, sunset views | Yes |
| The Crow's Nest | $$$$ | Impossible in July | Special occasions | No |
| Gosman's Dock | $$ | Walk-ins only | Families, casual vibe | Yes |
Quick Bites That Don't Compromise Quality
Sometimes you just need fuel between beach sessions. These spots prove fast doesn't mean flavorless:
Montauk Taco Co.
34 Star Island Road • No phone • 11:30AM-7PM
Must try: Fish tacos ($16 for two) with jalapeño slaw
Lines: Move surprisingly fast even when 20 people deep
Secret menu: Ask for "surfer style" - extra crispy fish with mango salsa
John's Drive-In
677 Montauk Highway • (631) 668-5339 • 11AM-8PM
Iconic: Been flipping burgers since 1963
What to order: Double bacon cheeseburger ($15), frosty root beer float ($6)
Warning: Cash only and zero ambiance. It's a parking lot with picnic tables.
Why I love it: Tastes like summer in a paper basket.
Pro move: Most restaurants in Montauk have brutal summer waits. Eat at off-hours - lunch at 11AM sharp, dinner before 6PM. You'll thank me later.
Where Locals Actually Eat When Tourists Leave
Want to escape the crowds? These under-the-radar spots are where Montauk residents eat year-round:
Liars Saloon
469 West Lake Drive • (631) 668-9595 • Opens 4PM
Vibe: Dark wood paneling, dart boards, smells like fried clams
Cheap eats: $12 fish sandwich Fridays, $1 oysters during happy hour (4-6PM)
Local tip: Bartender Mike makes the best Bloody Mary on the East End
Tutto Il Giorno
58 South Elmwood • (631) 668-4800 • Dinner from 5PM
Not cheap but: Their $24 homemade pasta specials change daily
Why locals go: Consistent quality even in February when other places close
Reality check: Parking in Montauk is brutal July-August. If you're hitting multiple restaurants in Montauk, consider biking or using the free shuttle that runs along Main Street till midnight.
Decoding Montauk Restaurant Costs
Let's talk money because Montauk sticker shock is real. Here's what you actually pay:
| Experience Level | Sample Restaurants | Avg Meal Cost | Worth It For |
|---|---|---|---|
| Budget Eats | John's Drive-In, Pizza Village | $15-25 per person | Quick lunches, families |
| Mid-Range | Liars Saloon, Montauk Taco Co. | $30-50 per person | Casual dinners, groups |
| High End | Scarpetta, Crow's Nest | $75-150+ per person | Special occasions, views |
What does this mean? That lobster roll you've heard about? Probably $34. Beachside cocktail? $18 before tip. My advice: Budget $100/day per person for food if eating out all meals. Ouch, I know.
Montauk Dining FAQs Answered Straight
When do most restaurants in Montauk open for the season?
Memorial Day weekend is when 90% flip their signs to "Open." Some year-round gems like Liars Saloon stay open, but your seafood options dwindle after October. Never trust a restaurant's offseason hours without calling first - I've shown up to locked doors too many times.
Can you eat well in Montauk without a car?
Surprisingly yes. Everything near downtown is walkable, and the free shuttle hits major spots like Gosman's Dock and Duryea's. But if you want to explore further? Uber exists but costs $25+ for short hops. Better to rent bikes.
Which Montauk restaurants take reservations?
Most nicer places do via Resy or OpenTable. But the surf-shack vibe spots? First come, first served. Pro tip: Set Resy alerts 30 days out for hot spots. For walk-ins, arrive at 5PM sharp or risk 2-hour waits.
Where can I find vegetarian/vegan options?
Joni's has killer plant-based breakfasts. Most dinner spots offer 1-2 veg entrees, but honestly? Montauk isn't vegan paradise. You'll find options, just not creativity. The taco place does good cauliflower tacos though.
What's the tipping situation?
Standard 18-20% for table service. Counter spots? They'll have tip jars but 10% is plenty. Watch your bill - some tourist traps add "healthcare surcharge" or "seasonal fee" nonsense. Always question those.
Are there any waterfront restaurants worth the hype?
Duryea's for casual lobster rolls with water views. Navy Beach for sunset drinks. Gosman's for family-friendly dining overlooking boats. Avoid places with "view" in the name charging $30 for frozen shrimp - seen it happen.
What's the best meal you've had in Montauk?
Personal favorite: September dinner at Navy Beach. Grilled octopus followed by local black sea bass, watching the sky turn pink. Cost me $120 with wine but didn't regret a penny. Worst? That overpriced brunch place near the circle. Dry eggs, sour coffee, $90 down the drain.
Making the Most of Montauk's Restaurant Scene
After all these years eating here, here's my hard-won advice: Don't overplan. Some of my best Montauk meals happened by stumbling into half-empty places at 3PM. Ask fishermen where they eat - usually leads to gems. And accept that you'll overpay sometimes. It's vacation tax.
Remember seasons matter. July crowds mean long waits and cranky servers. Come September? Easier reservations, fresher seafood, happier staff. I once got upgraded to a window table at Scarpetta just for complimenting the chef's pasta technique.
Montauk restaurants reflect the town - sometimes rough around the edges but full of character. Skip the Instagram traps. Find places with peeling paint and handwritten signs. That's where the magic happens.
Final thought? That little pizza place next to the laundromat. Looks sketchy. Best $4 slice you'll ever have. Sometimes you gotta trust the faded neon.
Comment