Let's be real – when someone mentions Chicago, two things pop into your head: freezing winters and deep dish Chicago style pizza. But here's the thing most articles won't tell you: not all deep dish pizzas are created equal. I learned this the hard way when I dragged my cousin from New York to Lou Malnati's last winter. He took one look at that buttery crust piled high with cheese and said, "That's not pizza, that's a casserole." Took us three days to speak again. Funny how food debates get personal.
What Makes Chicago Deep Dish Pizza Different?
Okay, picture this: You order a regular pizza. Thin crust, toppings scattered about. Now imagine someone took that concept, flipped it upside down, and baked it in a steel pan that weighs more than your cat. That's deep dish pizza Chicago style for you. The crust isn't just thicker – it's a whole structural engineering project. You've got:
• Buttery crust walls rising 1-2 inches tall (like a savory pie crust)
• Cheese layered DIRECTLY on the dough (this prevents sogginess)
• Toppings piled on top of the cheese (sausage patties are iconic)
• Chunky tomato sauce smothered on top (never buried underneath)
The first time I tried authentic Chicago deep dish, I made the rookie mistake of picking up a slice. Tomato sauce went everywhere – my white shirt looked like a crime scene. You need a fork and knife, period. And maybe a bib.
History Lesson in a Pan
Chicago didn't just wake up one day deciding to reinvent pizza. Back in 1943, Pizzeria Uno's founders Ike Sewell and Ric Riccardo wanted something heartier than thin-crust pies. Their creation? A pizza baked in a deep pan like a cake tin, designed to fill up hungry factory workers. Clever, right? Now Chicagoans defend this creation like it's their firstborn.
Top Chicago Deep Dish Pizza Spots (Tested & Ranked)
I've eaten my way through Chicago's pizza joints for years – sometimes regretting it the next morning. Here's the real deal on where to go:
| Pizzeria | Signature Pie | Price Range | Wait Time | Local Tip |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Lou Malnati's | The Malnati Chicago Classic (butter crust!) | $24-$32 (medium) | 45+ mins weekends | Order "The Lou" - spinach mix under the sauce |
| Giordano's | Stuffed Deep Dish (like a calzone-pizza hybrid) | $26-$35 (medium) | 1 hour+ (order ahead!) | Lunch specials save you $5 |
| Pequod's | Caramelized crust pan pizza (not traditional but iconic) | $22-$30 (medium) | 30-50 mins | Get extra caramelized edges! |
| Gino's East | Meaty Legend (sausage, pepperoni, bacon) | $25-$34 (medium) | 40-60 mins | Write on the walls - it's tradition |
Quick confession: Pequod's isn't technically "classic" Chicago deep dish – it's a pan pizza with that insane caramelized crust. But locals adore it, so I'd feel guilty leaving it out. Try it on a Tuesday when it's less chaotic.
The Cooking Ritual
Ever wonder why you wait 45 minutes for a Chicago style deep dish pizza? That's not inefficiency – it's science. That thick crust needs low, slow baking (usually 30-40 mins) to cook through without burning. If your pizza arrives in 15 minutes? It ain't legit deep dish. I learned this when my impatient friend demanded a "quick" version. What arrived was basically a sad, undercooked dough bowl.
Your Burning Questions About Chicago Deep Dish Pizza
Q: Is deep dish pizza just for tourists?
A: Heck no! Locals absolutely eat it – we just don't stand in hour-long lines. Weekday lunch specials or takeout during Bears games are how Chicagoans do it. My neighbor orders Lou's every Thanksgiving instead of turkey.
Q: Can you get Chicago deep dish outside Illinois?
A: Yes, but... Lou Malnati's ships frozen nationwide (surprisingly good!). Some chain spots like Giordano's have outposts in Florida/Arizona. But here's my take: it's never quite as good as eating it fresh in Chicago. The crust loses magic in transit.
Q: Why is it so expensive?
A: Three reasons: massive ingredient quantities (a medium feeds 3-4 people), specialty steel pans, and labor-intensive prep. But compare it to steakhouse prices – $30 for a filling meal isn't crazy.
Making Chicago Deep Dish at Home (It's Messy!)
During lockdown, I attempted homemade Chicago style pizza deep dish. Spoiler: my kitchen looked bombed. But here's the distilled wisdom from my flour-covered disasters:
The Crucial Steps Most Recipes Get Wrong:
1. Use cornmeal AND butter in the crust (not just flour)
2. Par-bake the crust 10 mins BEFORE adding fillings
3. Layer in this order: cheese → toppings → sauce (NEVER sauce first!)
4. Bake in a real steel pan (cake pans leak butter everywhere. Learned that the hard way.)
My biggest mistake? Overloading toppings. Too many veggies make the center soggy. Stick to 2-3 max. And use block mozzarella you shred yourself – pre-shredded cheese has anti-caking junk that screws up texture.
Essential Gear for Home Chefs
• Deep 10-inch steel pan (Lodge brand works great)
• Pizza stone or steel for oven floor
• Sturdy metal spatula (plastic will snap)
• Pastry brush for buttering crust edges
Pro Tip: Freeze leftover slices individually wrapped. Reheats perfectly in air fryer at 375°F for 8 mins. Better than fresh? Don't tell any Chicagoans I said that.
Why People Either Love or Hate Deep Dish
Let's address the elephant in the room: New Yorkers think our pizza is a lasagna imposter. And honestly? I get it. If you expect floppy thin crust, deep dish Chicago style pizza feels alien. It eats more like a savory pie – dense, rich, fork-and-knife territory.
Here's my balanced take: Deep dish isn't "better" than other pizzas. It's just different. Like comparing burgers to tacos. Order it when you want:
• Comfort food that sticks to your ribs
• Sharing experience (nobody finishes a medium alone)
• Something uniquely Chicago
But if you want quick, cheap slices? Grab thin crust. Even I don't eat deep dish weekly – my arteries couldn't handle it.
Pairings That Actually Work
Skip the obvious soda pairings. After taste-testing combos at Pequod's bar, here's what cuts through the richness:
• Craft Root Beer (the vanilla/spice balances tomatoes)
• Dry Italian Red Wine (Chianti Classico works best)
• Hoppy Pale Ale (Goose Island IPA is Chicago-approved)
• Sparkling Water + Lemon (for cleanup between bites)
Never pair with heavy beer or sweet cocktails – you'll feel like a stuffed turkey. And yes, leftovers exist! Cold deep dish for breakfast tastes shockingly good.
Beyond the Cheese: Regional Twists
Not all Chicago deep dish pizzas follow the same script. Over decades, substyles emerged:
| Style | Key Features | Who Does It Best |
|---|---|---|
| Stuffed Pizza | Extra dough layer UNDER sauce (like a top crust) | Giordano's, Nancy's |
| Butter Crust | Rich, flaky pastry-like base | Lou Malnati's signature |
| Caramelized Edge | Cheese baked onto pan edges creates crispy crust | Pequod's, Burt's Place |
My controversial opinion? Stuffed pizza crosses into "too much" territory. Feels like eating a dough brick. But tourists adore the cheese explosions for Instagram.
Deep Dish Etiquette 101
Don't embarrass yourself in a Chicago pizzeria. Follow these unspoken rules:
• Reserve ahead - Seriously. Just call.
• Slice count matters - Small: 4 slices, Medium: 6, Large: 8
• Toppings go UNDER sauce - Asking for extra sauce on top? That's criminal.
• No dipping sauces - Ranch with deep dish? You'll get side-eye.
• Tipping - 18-20% since servers deal with heavy pans
Last tip: Wear stretchy pants. No joke. After finishing two slices of proper deep dish Chicago style pizza, your jeans button will hate you.
Final Thoughts From a Chicago Native
Deep dish isn't fast food. It's culinary theater – labor-intensive, decadent, borderline excessive. Come starving, bring friends, and surrender to the experience. Is it "real" pizza? Honestly, who cares? When that buttery crust meets tangy tomatoes and gooey cheese... labels stop mattering.
Just promise me one thing: If you visit Chicago, try both deep dish AND our killer tavern-style thin crust. Pizza tribalism is exhausting. Life's too short to limit yourself to one dough thickness.
Comment