So you found a 1960 penny in Grandpa's old coin jar or maybe in your morning coffee change. That little copper disc suddenly feels heavy with possibility, doesn't it? I remember digging through rolls of pennies back in college, hoping to strike it rich. Found three 1960s in one roll once - got way too excited before realizing most aren't goldmines. Let's cut through the hype and talk real numbers.
Not All 1960 Pennies Are Created Equal
First thing you gotta understand: that date alone doesn't mean much. I learned this the hard way when I tried selling my first "rare" 1960 penny to a dealer who just chuckled. Three factors actually matter:
- Mint Mark (or lack thereof): Look under Lincoln's shoulder blades on the reverse. See a tiny "D"? That's Denver. No letter? Philadelphia. This changes everything.
- Variety: Two totally different reverse designs exist - the "Large Date" and "Small Date". One is common, the other... well, we'll get there.
- Condition: A scratched-up penny might buy you a gumball. A pristine one? Could pay your electric bill.
Small Date vs. Large Date: The Million-Dollar Difference?
Here's where collectors get sweaty palms. Most 1960 pennies have a Large Date - the numbers look... well, large. But a tiny fraction have a Small Date where the "9" and "6" are noticeably smaller and closer together.
| Variety | How to Spot It | Survival Estimate |
|---|---|---|
| Large Date | "9" has curved base, "6" is wider | Billions minted |
| Small Date | "9" has straight base, "6" is narrow | Fewer than 20,000 exist |
Why the fuss? The Small Date was a minting error corrected early in production. Finding one is like spotting a four-leaf clover in a wheat field. I've handled maybe two legit Small Dates in 10 years of coin hunting. If yours has:
- A "9" with a flat bottom edge
- A skinny "6"
- No doubling on letters (common fakes)
...you might want to sit down before checking valuations.
What's the Actual Worth of a 1960 Penny?
Time for numbers. Below isn't dealer hype - it's compiled from actual 2023 auction results and my own trading experience. Remember: these are retail prices. Dealers pay 30-60% less (they gotta eat too).
1960 Penny (Philadelphia - No Mint Mark) Value
| Condition | Large Date Value | Small Date Value |
|---|---|---|
| Worn (G-4) | $0.02 - Face value | $15 - $35 |
| Very Fine (VF-20) | $0.25 - $0.50 | $175 - $400 |
| Mint State (MS-60) | $1 - $3 | $1,000 - $2,500 |
| Gem Mint (MS-65+) | $15 - $60 | $10,000 - $30,000+ |
See why condition matters? A perfect Philly Small Date sold for $31,200 in 2019. Makes you look at pocket change differently, huh?
1960-D Penny (Denver) Value
Denver minted way more pennies than Philly in 1960. No confirmed Small Dates exist from Denver - if someone tries to sell you one, run. Here's reality:
| Condition | Value Range |
|---|---|
| Circulated (VG-8) | $0.02 - $0.10 |
| Extremely Fine (EF-40) | $0.50 - $1.50 |
| Mint State (MS-63) | $3 - $10 |
| Premium Gem (MS-67+) | $150 - $1,200+ |
Grading Your Coin Like a Pro (Without Paying $50)
Professional grading costs $25-$150 per coin. For most 1960 pennies, that's overkill. Use this cheat sheet:
- Basics:
- Worn (G-VG): Lincoln's cheekbone smooth, letters blend with rim
- Fine (F): Some cheekbone detail, "TRUST" readable
- Very Fine (VF): Full cheekbone, wheat stalks defined
- Uncirculated Checklist:
- Luster: Should glow under light, not dull
- Contact Marks: Fewer than 3-5 visible nicks
- Color: Even chocolate-brown (no spots)
"When in doubt, assume it's graded two levels lower than you think. Wish I'd known that before overgrading my first collection." - Me after my eBay beginner mistakes
Selling Your 1960 Penny: Don't Get Ripped Off
Found a winner? Here's how to cash in without regrets:
Where to Sell Ranked by Value Retention
| Venue | Best For | Commission/Fees | Speed |
|---|---|---|---|
| Coin Dealer | Quick sale under $500 | 30-50% below retail | Same day |
| eBay | Coins $100-$5,000 | 13% + payment fees | 1-2 weeks |
| Heritage Auctions | Rare coins over $1,000 | 20% buyer premium + seller fees | 3-6 months |
| Coin Forums (Reddit/Collectors) | No fees but requires trust | 0% (but PayPal fees) | Varies |
For coins under $100? Honestly, your local coin shop is easiest. Yeah, they profit - but they also authenticate and pay cash immediately. Sold my first VF Small Date for $85 at a shop. Could've gotten $120 on eBay... after fees, shipping, and 3 weeks of buyer drama.
FAQ: Your Burning Questions Answered
Do all 1960 pennies contain silver?
Nope - that's a persistent myth. 1960 pennies are 95% copper, 5% zinc. Same as today (except modern pennies are zinc with copper plating). Melt value is about 2.5 cents but illegal to melt US coins.
Why does my 1960 penny look shiny and new?
Probably replated - a common trick to fool newbies. Genuine mint luster has subtle "cartwheel" effect when rotated under light. Replated coins look artificially bright and lack detail in protected areas like letter crevices. Saw dozens at flea markets last summer.
Are there any known errors besides Small Dates?
A few exist but are extremely rare:
- Doubled Die Obverse: Visible doubling on "IN GOD WE TRUST"
- Repunched Mintmark: D shows slight doubling or notching (only on 1960-D)
Should I clean my dirty 1960 penny?
Absolutely NOT! Cleaning destroys surface details and value. A professionally conserved coin sells for 50% less than uncleaned. Found a crusty 1960 in my garden once. Left the dirt - sold as "honest original" for $40.
Bottom Line: Should You Keep Hunting?
Unless you've got a pristine Small Date, don't quit your job. But checking dates costs nothing. My strategy:
- Search every wheat-back penny (pre-1959 design ended in 1958)
- Check 1960/1960-D coins for Small Date features
- Save anything AU or better (minimal wear)
The worth of a 1960 penny fascinates collectors because it's common enough to find, rare enough to excite. Last month a client found one in a tip jar - graded MS-64RB, sold it for $350. Not life-changing, but pays for the coffee habit that found it.
Still unsure about your coin? Snap clear front/back photos and email reputable dealers like ANACS or PCGS for free estimates. Just avoid those "we buy rare coins" TV guys - their offers made me laugh till I cried. Happy hunting!
Comment