So you've got a 1939 Mercury dime? That little silver coin with the winged Liberty head might be worth more than you think. I remember when I found my first Mercury dime in my grandpa's coin jar years ago. Thought it was just pocket change until I did some digging. These dimes have stories to tell, and more importantly, cash value. Let's cut through the noise and break down what really affects that 1939 Mercury dime value sitting in your collection.
Why This Tiny Silver Coin Matters
Designed by Adolph Weinman in 1916, Mercury dimes (actually featuring Liberty with a winged cap) circulated until 1945. The 1939 version came from three mints: Philadelphia (no mint mark), Denver (D), and San Francisco (S). What fascinates me isn't just the coin's history, but how its value shifts based on tiny details most people overlook. Like that little mint mark under the "E" in "ONE" on the reverse. Miss that, and you might undervalue your coin by hundreds.
Key Factors That Drive 1939 Mercury Dime Value
Condition is everything. I've seen two 1939 dimes that looked nearly identical at first glance, but one had original luster while the other was polished. Guess which one sold for 10x more? Grading is brutal but honest. Here's what actually matters:
- Mint mark location: Coins from Denver (D) are tougher to find in top condition than Philadelphia issues
- Surface wear: Check Liberty's cheek and forehead - wear shows there first
- Original luster: That frosty shine can't be faked well (trust me, I've seen attempts)
- Toning: Natural rainbow hues add value; artificial toning kills it
- Strike quality: Weak details on wheat ears or fasces bundle reduce value
1939 Mercury Dime Value By Grade and Mint Mark
Let's get specific. These numbers come from actual auction sales I've tracked over the past year, not just generic price guides. You'll notice something interesting about San Francisco coins in mid-grades...
| Condition | No Mint (Philadelphia) | D Mint (Denver) | S Mint (San Francisco) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Good (G-4) | $2.50 - $3.50 | $3 - $4 | $3 - $5 |
| Very Good (VG-8) | $3 - $4.50 | $4 - $6 | $4 - $7 |
| Fine (F-12) | $4 - $6 | $5 - $8 | $6 - $11 |
| Very Fine (VF-20) | $5 - $8 | $7 - $12 | $10 - $18 |
| Extra Fine (EF-40) | $8 - $15 | $12 - $22 | $18 - $35 |
| AU-50 (About Uncirculated) | $15 - $25 | $25 - $40 | $35 - $60 |
| MS-63 (Uncirculated) | $45 - $65 | $70 - $100 | $100 - $150 |
| MS-65 (Gem Uncirculated) | $150 - $250 | $250 - $400 | $400 - $650 |
| MS-67 (Superb Gem) | $1,500+ | $3,000+ | $4,000+ |
Note: Values updated Q2 2023 based on PCGS auction archives and dealer transactions. Premiums apply for CAC-approved coins.
The Rare Ones That Break the Rules
Okay, here's where things get wild. While most 1939 dimes follow the above values, exceptions exist:
- Full Bands examples: Coins with complete horizontal lines on the fasces (center bundle) command massive premiums. An MS-67 FB recently sold for $14,500 at auction
- Proof issues: Only 10-15 exist, last one traded privately for $25k+ in 2021
- "Micro D" variety: A tiny mint mark variant unique to Denver coins adds 30-50% value in mid-grades
I once saw a collector pay $800 for a coin graded MS-64 because it had rainbow toning around the edges. Seemed crazy to me until I checked auction archives - turns out it was actually a bargain.
Spotting Fakes and Problem Coins
Here's the ugly truth: about 30% of raw "uncirculated" 1939 Mercury dimes I examine have issues. Common problems I've found:
| Problem | How to Detect | Value Impact |
|---|---|---|
| Cleaning | Hairline scratches in same direction, dull surfaces | Reduces value 50-90% |
| Artificial Toning | Uneven color bands, unnatural blues/purples | Makes coin nearly worthless |
| Tooled Details | Metal flow disruption around letters/features | Kills collector value |
| Counterfeits | Wrong weight (should be 2.5g), soft details | Worthless |
My advice? Buy a cheap digital scale. Real Mercury dimes weigh exactly 2.50 grams. If it's off by more than 0.05g, something's wrong. Simple trick that saved me from buying two fakes last year.
Where Your 1939 Mercury Dime Value Actually Comes From
Breakdown of value sources based on grade:
- Low-grade (G-VG): 90% silver content ($1.75 melt as of Aug 2023)
- Mid-grade (F-XF): Collector demand for type sets
- Uncirculated (MS-60+): Rarity of well-preserved examples
- Gem (MS-65+): Competitive registry set demand
Honest opinion? Unless you've got a true gem, the 1939 Mercury dime value isn't life-changing. But that's not why we collect coins, is it? There's magic in holding history. Just manage expectations.
Getting the Best Price When Selling
From experience, where you sell impacts final value more than you'd think:
| Sales Method | Expected % of Retail Value | Best For | Timeframe |
|---|---|---|---|
| Coin Dealer Purchase | 40-60% | Quick cash | Immediate |
| Auction House Consignment | 70-85% (after fees) | Rare coins ($500+) | 3-6 months |
| Online Marketplace (eBay) | 85-95% | Common to mid-grade | 1-4 weeks |
| Coin Show Direct Sale | 65-80% | Informed negotiation | Weekend |
Pro tip: Get multiple offers. I once sold an MS-64 1939-S for $120 at a coin shop, later saw same dealer list it for $299. Lesson learned.
Grading Costs - Is It Worth It?
Breakdown for professional grading:
- PCGS/NGC fees: $25-$45 per coin plus shipping
- Turnaround time: 30-60 days standard service
- Break-even point: Only grade coins worth $150+ raw
- Value boost: MS-63 coins gain 20-40% premium in holder
Personal rule: I never grade coins worth under $100. The math rarely works out. For common-date Mercury dimes in XF-AU, just enjoy them raw.
Your Top 1939 Mercury Dime Questions Answered
How much silver is in a 1939 dime?
Each contains 0.07234 oz of 90% pure silver. At current silver prices ($23/oz), that's about $1.66 in melt value. But honestly, you'd be crazy to melt one - collector value always exceeds melt unless it's completely worn flat.
Why are some 1939 dimes worth thousands?
Extremely high-grade examples (MS-67+) are rare survivors. Only 1 in 5,000 original coins still exist in gem condition. The 1939 Mercury dime value skyrockets when you hit MS-66 or higher, especially with Full Bands details.
Should I clean my old dime?
Never. I made this mistake with my first Mercury dime. Cleaning permanently scratches surfaces and destroys collector value. Even if it looks dirty, leave it alone. Professional conservation exists but costs more than most 1939 dimes are worth.
Where is the mint mark on a 1939 Mercury dime?
Reverse side, bottom left near the rim, just below the E in "ONE CENT". Philadelphia coins have no mint mark, Denver shows "D", San Francisco "S". Use a 5x loupe - sometimes they're faint.
Are there any rare errors for this year?
The 1939-D "Micro D" variety (small mint mark) carries slight premium. Major errors like off-center strikes are rare but valuable. I once saw a 30% off-center 1939 sell for $350. But common minor imperfections add zero value.
Future Outlook for 1939 Mercury Dime Value
Market trends I'm noticing:
- Short-term (1-2 years): Flat for common grades, 5-10% growth potential for gems
- Silver factor: Prices could jump if silver spikes over $30/oz
- Generation shift: Younger collectors prefer Mercury dimes over older types
- Registry risk: High-end values depend on wealthy collectors competing for sets
Frankly, Mercury dimes aren't the hottest series right now. But they're stable. Unlike some modern issues, these have stood the test of time. I'd buy any problem-free MS-65 or better example at fair prices.
Final Reality Check
Unless you've got that perfect MS-67 coin, your 1939 Mercury dime won't fund retirement. But as a tangible piece of Depression-era history? Priceless. Check those mint marks, examine surfaces carefully, and most importantly - enjoy the hunt. That's where the real value lies.
Found a 1939 dime you want evaluated? Feel free to reach out - I'll give you my honest opinion with no sales pressure. Just don't send me photos of common circulated coins worth $3.50. Seen enough of those to last a lifetime.
Comment