Remember my first encounter with a double reed instrument? It was at a flea market in Vienna - this dusty old oboe sitting next to a pile of vinyl records. The stall owner warned me: "Those things will drive you nuts before they sing." Boy was he right. But when you finally make one sing? Pure magic. Today let's unpack everything about these fascinating noisemakers.
What Exactly Defines a Double Reed Instrument?
At its core, a double reeded musical instrument uses two pieces of cane vibrating against each other. Unlike single reeds (like clarinets) that slap against a mouthpiece, double reeds create sound through this delicate cane-on-cane action. That's why they've got that distinctive nasal tone - sometimes sweet, sometimes like an angry goose.
Funny story: My neighbor once called the police thinking someone was strangling ducks when I was practicing my beginner oboe reeds. True story. The cop actually complimented my "progress" after hearing me play three months later.
The Physics Behind the Buzz
Here's why double reeds work differently: when air pressure builds between the two reeds, they snap shut then spring open rapidly. This happens thousands of times per second creating sound waves. The tighter the scrape on the cane, the brighter and more penetrating the sound.
| Reed Type | Vibration Pattern | Sound Character | Air Pressure Needed |
|---|---|---|---|
| Double reed (e.g. oboe) | Cane-on-cane vibration | Nasal, penetrating | Very high (like blowing up a stiff balloon) |
| Single reed (e.g. clarinet) | Cane against mouthpiece | Warm, rounded | Moderate |
| Lip reed (e.g. trumpet) | Lips vibrating in cup | Brassy, brilliant | Medium-high |
Meet the Double Reed Family Members
Most folks only know the oboe and bassoon, but there's a whole zoo of double reed instruments out there. Some are historical relics, others are still breathing fire in modern ensembles.
The Main Players in Western Music
| Instrument | Pitch Range | Role in Ensemble | Reed Size (compared to oboe) | Learning Difficulty |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Oboe | B♭3 to A6 | Melody/solo lines | Standard (1x) | Very High (embouchure torture!) |
| English Horn | E3 to B5 | Lyrical solos | 1.5x larger | High (like oboe but heavier) |
| Bassoon | B♭1 to E5 | Bass line/comedy | 4x larger | Extremely High (finger stretch nightmare) |
| Contrabassoon | A0 to C4 | Foundation bass | 6x larger | Brutal (requires lung capacity of a whale) |
English horn reeds frustrate me personally - they're just big enough to feel awkward but not so big that you can really grip them comfortably. Always feels like trying to hold a wet bar of soap.
Global Double Reed Oddities
- Shawm: Medieval ancestor of the oboe. Sounds like a chainsaw chorus. I played one at a Renaissance fair once and cleared a 30-foot radius.
- Piña: From the Philippines. Terrifyingly loud with a vibrating metal ring that gives it this buzzing edge.
- Suona: Chinese double reed used in weddings and funerals. Makes your ears bleed in the best possible way.
Choosing Your First Double Reed Instrument
Seeing a pattern here? These instruments hate beginners. But if you're dead set on joining the double reed cult, here's what to consider.
The Financial Reality Check
Let's be brutally honest - double reed instruments will empty your wallet faster than a Vegas slot machine. Why?
- Reeds are disposable: Expect to replace them monthly ($15-35 per reed)
- Specialized repairs: A bent oboe key costs $200+ to fix
- Entry-level costs: Decent student oboes start around $2,500
My first bassoon cost more than my car. The repair bills later that year cost more than my insurance deductible. Worth it? Ask me during a good reed day.
| Instrument | Good Student Model Price | Professional Model Price | Annual Reed Cost | Essential Accessories |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Oboe | $1,800-$3,000 | $6,000-$15,000 | $200-$500 | Reed case, humidity gauge, thread, plaque |
| Bassoon | $5,000-$8,000 | $15,000-$35,000 | $400-$800 | Seat strap, bocal, swab, reed tools |
Notice how professional bassoons cost as much as a luxury vacation? Yeah. That still keeps me up at night.
The Skill Commitment
Here's the raw truth about learning curve compared to other instruments:
- First sound production: Takes weeks (vs. hours for flute or sax)
- Acceptable tone development: 1-2 years minimum
- Reed making mastery: 5+ years if ever accomplished
My college professor used to say: "If you can stick with oboe for three years without crying weekly, you might have a shot." He wasn't joking.
Survival Guide for Double Reed Players
After twenty years of reeds cracking at the worst moments, here are my battle-tested tips.
Reed Maintenance Rituals
- The morning soak: 2 minutes in water (spit works in emergencies)
- Rotate reeds: Never play the same reed twice in one day
- Storage: Reed cases with humidity control (65% RH ideal)
- Travel rule: Always carry 3 playable reeds minimum
I learned that last rule the hard way during a tour in Arizona. Dry air turned my last good reed into a potato chip mid-concerto. Never again.
Essential Reed Tool Kit
Every double reed player needs these tools within reach:
| Tool | Purpose | Cost Range | DIY Alternative |
|---|---|---|---|
| Reed knife | Scraping cane | $80-$200 | Razor blade (risky!) |
| Mandrel | Holding reed while tying | $30-$60 | Sharpened pencil (not recommended) |
| Plaque | Protects blades during scraping | $15-$40 | Guitar pick (works surprisingly well) |
| Cutting block | Stabilizes reed for clipping | $25-$70 | Granite sample from hardware store |
Why Choose This Torture? The Magic Moments
Despite everything, here's why we endure the double reed struggle:
- The solo spotlight: Ever notice how movie emotional scenes feature oboes? (Titanic, Schindler's List)
- Orchestral indispensability: That famous tuning note? Always the oboe's job
- Unique repertoire: Composers write specifically for these timbres
When my bassoon section nailed the Rite of Spring bassoon solo after six months of practice? Chills. Absolute chills. That's the drug that keeps us hooked.
Double Reed FAQ: Real Questions from Beginners
Can I teach myself a double reed instrument?
Honestly? Don't. Unlike guitar or piano, bad habits will destroy your progress. The embouchure alone requires expert feedback. I wasted six months self-teaching before finding a teacher who fixed my jaw position in ten minutes.
Why do double reed instruments cost so much?
Three reasons: complexity (oboe has 45+ tiny keys), low production volume (maybe 3,000 oboes made annually vs. 50,000+ clarinets), and specialist labor (master craftsmen spend 100+ hours per instrument).
Are synthetic reeds any good?
Mixed bag. For bassoon, Legère reeds ($130) work decently in emergencies. For oboe? Still sound like kazoos to my ear. The cane response just isn't there yet. Maybe in another decade.
Which is harder: oboe or bassoon?
Oboe wins for embouchure pain, bassoon for finger gymnastics. Bassoonists need spider hands to reach some keys. Oboists develop scary lip muscles. Both will humble you constantly.
How often should I replace reeds?
Depends on play frequency:
- Students: 1-2 reeds per month
- Amateur players: 6-8 reeds annually
- Pros: 50+ reeds per year (tour schedules kill reeds)
Crafting Your Sound: Advanced Techniques
Once you survive the beginner phase, these skills separate hobbyists from artists.
Specialized Articulations
- Flutter-tonguing: Roll your R's while playing (works better on bassoon)
- Sul ponticello: Play near the reed thread for glassy tones
- Multiphonics: Finger one note but sing another (bassoon excels at this)
Modern composers love torture... I mean extended techniques. Had to learn duck calls for one avant-garde piece. The audience looked horrified.
Reed Customization Secrets
Tailoring reeds transforms your sound:
| Adjustment | Tool Used | Effect on Sound | Risk Level |
|---|---|---|---|
| Scrape tip | Knife | Brightens tone | High (easy to overdo) |
| Clip tip length | Clippers | Quickens response | Medium (permanent change) |
| Adjust opening | Pliers | Changes resistance | Extreme (instant reed death if wrong) |
My golden rule: never adjust a gig reed before a performance. Made that mistake during a Wagner opera. The high C came out as a squeak. Conductor's glare still haunts me.
Career Paths for Double Reed Warriors
Surprisingly diverse options beyond orchestra pits:
- Studio musicians: Film/TV recording sessions pay well for reed doubling skills
- Military bands: Steady pay and travel opportunities
- Reed making: Top artisans charge $50-$150 per reed with waiting lists
- Historical performance: Baroque oboe specialists are rare unicorns
My weirdest gig? Playing contrabassoon for a death metal band's symphonic album. The vibration nearly shook my fillings loose. Paid triple scale though.
The Dark Side of Double Reeds
Let's not sugarcoat the frustrations:
- Reed inconsistencies: Humidity changes can ruin a perfect reed overnight
- Physical strain: Bassoonists get back problems, oboists develop TMJ
- Limited repertoire: You'll play Mozart and Strauss until you dream in C major
There's a reason brass players mock us. During Mahler 1 rehearsals last year, the trumpet section bet on how many reeds I'd break. I lost $20.
Why Double Reeds Still Captivate Us
Despite everything, that magical moment when cane vibrates perfectly? Unmatched. The way an English horn solo can make an audience collectively hold their breath? Priceless. No other double reeded musical instrument creates that human-organic connection. It's like singing through carved grass.
Final thought: Try one if you dare. Borrow a school oboe, take three lessons. When you finally produce a clear middle C, you'll either run screaming or get hooked for life. No middle ground with these beasts. Beautiful, frustrating, expensive beasts.
Comment