Okay, let's talk turkey. Literally. That warm, fuzzy feeling you get thinking about Thanksgiving – the big meal, the family chaos, the football game blaring in the background? It's wrapped up in this idea of Pilgrims and Native Americans sharing a peaceful feast back in 1621. But when you start digging into the actual thanksgiving history of America, things get... well, less simple, and honestly, a lot more interesting. It wasn't just one meal, and it definitely wasn't called "Thanksgiving" back then. So, how did we get from a three-day harvest gathering in Plymouth to a national holiday centered on giant parades and insane shopping deals? Buckle up.
Here’s the thing most people get wrong right off the bat: that 1621 event in Plymouth Colony (present-day Massachusetts)? The Pilgrims themselves wouldn’t have called it "Thanksgiving." Back then, a "thanksgiving" was a serious religious event. Think prayer, fasting (yep, fasting!), and sermons that could go on for hours. Not exactly parades and pumpkin pie. What happened in 1621 was a harvest celebration. A successful harvest meant survival through the brutal winter. They were grateful, sure, deeply grateful, but it wasn't that formal religious day of thanksgiving. The Wampanoag people, led by Ousamequin (Massasoit), showed up – probably about 90 warriors – likely heard the gunfire from the English hunting and came to see what was up. They stayed for three days. History records they contributed five deer. Imagine the logistics!
Beyond Plymouth: The Messy Roots of Giving Thanks
While Plymouth gets the spotlight, pinning down the *true* first North American thanksgiving is a historian's nightmare. Other European settlers held days of thanksgiving way before 1621:
- Spanish in Florida (1565): Pedro Menéndez de Avilés and his crew, along with the local Timucua people, shared a meal after founding St. Augustine. Was it a formal "thanksgiving"? Debatable, but it involved giving thanks.
- Virginia (1619): Settlers at Berkeley Hundred were ordered by their charter to observe the day of their arrival (December 4th) "yearly and perpetually kept holy as a day of thanksgiving to Almighty God." That sounds pretty official! But harsh conditions meant this tradition didn't stick long-term.
See the pattern? Days of giving thanks were happening, but they were scattered, local, and often tied to specific survival milestones or religious decrees, not a harvest feast. The Plymouth event stuck in popular imagination partly because of later writings, especially those of William Bradford (Of Plymouth Plantation) and a letter by Edward Winslow mentioning the feast.
What Was Actually on the Menu? (Hint: Probably Not Pie)
Thinking about that 1621 table? Forget the modern spread. Historical records (mainly Winslow's letter) give us clues:
| Likely Present | Definitely Absent | Maybe? |
|---|---|---|
| Venison (lots of it, thanks to the Wampanoag) | Mashed Potatoes (Potatoes weren't widely cultivated in North America yet) | Wild Fowl (possibly including wild turkey, but also ducks, geese, swans) |
| Seafood (cod, bass, lobster, clams - abundant locally) | Cranberry Sauce (sugar was scarce and expensive) | Corn (prepared as porridge or bread, likely coarse) |
| Native Harvest (pumpkin, squash, beans - probably stewed) | Pumpkin Pie (no butter, flour, or ovens like we have) | Nuts (walnuts, chestnuts) |
| Wild Onions, Leeks, Garlic | Sweet Potatoes/Yams (not common in the North then) | Dried Fruits (if any were imported/saved) |
It was hearty, practical food based on what was freshly hunted, gathered, and harvested locally. The elaborate desserts and sides we pile onto our plates are centuries of tradition piled on top. Kinda makes you appreciate the convenience of modern ovens, doesn't it? Trying to roast a turkey over an open fire for 50+ people? No thanks.
My own attempt at a "historically inspired" side dish one year? Stewed pumpkin with onions. Let's just say the canned stuff flew off the shelf much faster.
From Local Thanksgivings to National Holiday: The Long Road
For over two centuries after Plymouth, Thanksgiving remained largely a regional thing. New England colonies regularly held autumn harvest thanksgivings or spring "fasting" days. These were proclaimed by governors or church leaders. Dates varied wildly. There was no single "Thanksgiving Day."
So how did it become *the* national holiday? Enter Sarah Josepha Hale. You might know her as the author of "Mary Had a Little Lamb." But her real passion project? Making Thanksgiving a national, unified holiday. For *decades* (seriously, like 36 years!), she wrote editorials in her popular magazine, Godey's Lady's Book, and sent countless letters to governors, senators, and presidents. She argued it would foster national unity, especially as tensions leading to the Civil War grew. She had a point – everyone could use a day focused on gratitude.
Then came the Civil War. Abraham Lincoln, seeking ways to unite a fractured nation, finally listened to Hale's persistent campaign. In October 1863, smack in the middle of the war's horrors, he issued a presidential proclamation setting aside the final Thursday in November as "a day of Thanksgiving and Praise." He asked citizens to pray for healing and care for widows, orphans, and soldiers. It was deeply rooted in the context of national trauma. That 1863 date is the real foundation of our modern, national Thanksgiving holiday. Makes you think about what we're collectively grateful for now, doesn't it?
For about 75 years, presidents annually declared Thanksgiving for that last Thursday. Then came the Great Depression. Hoping to boost Christmas sales by giving shoppers an extra week, President Franklin D. Roosevelt moved Thanksgiving up a week in 1939 to the *third* Thursday. Oh, the uproar! People called it "Franksgiving." Some states rebelled and stuck with the last Thursday. Chaos reigned for a couple of years. Finally, in 1941, Congress stepped in and passed a law: Thanksgiving would be the fourth Thursday in November. Every year. No more calendar confusion. Thank goodness.
The Evolution of Traditions: Turkey, Parades, and Football
How did turkey become the star? It wasn't instant. Goose, duck, even beef or pork were common centerpieces regionally. Turkey gained popularity because it was native, large enough to feed a crowd, and became associated with abundance. Promoting turkey as *the* Thanksgiving bird was partly a 19th-century marketing push by the poultry industry. And hey, it worked.
Parades? The big one started in 1924: Macy's Thanksgiving Day Parade in New York City. Originally a Christmas promotion featuring live animals from the Central Park Zoo (can you imagine balloons being easier?), it became a massive spectacle synonymous with Thanksgiving morning. Watching those giant floats weave through Manhattan – that’s a tradition glued to the holiday now.
And Football? College football games became linked with Thanksgiving as early as the 1870s. The NFL jumped in, establishing the Detroit Lions' Thanksgiving Day game tradition in 1934. It was a gamble to boost attendance during tough times, but it stuck. Now, for many, Thanksgiving isn't complete without the sounds of a game in the background, maybe sparking some friendly family rivalry. Pass the potatoes during a commercial break.
A More Honest Look: Complexity and Contemplation
This is where the feel-good story gets complicated, and frankly, where glossing over it does everyone a disservice. For many Native American peoples, Thanksgiving is a National Day of Mourning. It marks the beginning of centuries of colonialism, land theft, broken treaties, violence, and cultural erasure that followed European arrival. The relationship between the Wampanoag and the Pilgrims, while initially cooperative for survival, deteriorated rapidly due to land pressures, cultural clashes, and disease devastating Native populations.
Ignoring this painful legacy ignores the full picture of the thanksgiving history of this continent. The true story isn't just about one peaceful meal; it's about the centuries-long struggle and resilience of Indigenous nations. Understanding this complexity is crucial for an honest observance of the day today. It means acknowledging the past while reflecting on how we move forward.
Thinking about incorporating this perspective? Many communities hold sunrise gatherings on Thanksgiving Day acknowledging the National Day of Mourning. Learning about the history and culture of the Native peoples whose land you live on is a meaningful step. Supporting Indigenous creators, businesses, and causes year-round goes beyond just one day. It's about respect and reckoning.
Modern Thanksgiving: The Feast, The Frenzy, The Feels
Fast forward to today. Forget open-fire cooking. The Thanksgiving meal is arguably the biggest cooking event of the year for many households. The pressure! Travel chaos is real – airports and highways packed as people try to get home. Family dynamics can be... intense. It's a swirling mix of warmth, stress, tradition, and sometimes, awkward political debates at the table. Anyone else strategically seated between cousins who don't get along?
And then there's Black Friday. What started as post-Thanksgiving sales creeping into late Thursday has become a phenomenon all its own, sometimes overshadowing the holiday itself. Some folks love the hustle and deals; others lament the commercial takeover. Can't we just finish the pie first?
Navigating the Modern Meal: Classics & Variations
Despite regional twists (oyster stuffing in the South, green bean casserole everywhere now), some dishes are near-universal contenders:
- The Turkey: Roasted, deep-fried (carefully!), smoked, brined, spatchcocked – endless methods debated fiercely.
- Stuffing/Dressing: Cooked inside the bird or baked separately? Cornbread or white bread? Sausage? Chestnuts? This one sparks wars.
- Mashed Potatoes & Gravy: Creamy, lumpy? Gravy from drippings or a packet? Non-negotiable comfort food.
- Cranberry Sauce: Jellied cylinder from the can (a nostalgic favorite for many, admit it) or homemade relish with berries and orange zest? The great divide.
- Pumpkin Pie (and others): The classic finale, often with whipped cream. Apple, pecan, and sweet potato pie are strong runners-up.
Increasingly, folks are branching out: Turducken (turkey, duck, chicken), Tofurky for vegetarians/vegans, global fusion sides, or completely non-traditional meals. Hey, if everyone's happy and grateful, what's on the plate matters less than who's around it. Thanksgiving is nothing if not adaptable.
Digging Deeper: Your Thanksgiving History Questions Answered (FAQ)
Did the Pilgrims really call it "The First Thanksgiving"?
Nope, definitely not. That label came much later, way after the event itself. To them, it was a harvest celebration. The term "Thanksgiving" for an annual autumnal feast became popular centuries later.
Why is Thanksgiving always on a Thursday?
This traces back to those early Puritan traditions in New England. Days of thanksgiving (and days of fasting) were typically held on Thursdays. It was a practical choice, avoiding conflict with the Sabbath (Saturday for Jews, Sunday for Christians). Lincoln cemented the Thursday tradition nationally in 1863.
When did the Macy's Thanksgiving Day Parade start?
It kicked off in 1924 in New York City. Originally called the Macy's Christmas Parade, it featured floats, bands, and live animals borrowed from the Central Park Zoo! The giant inflatable balloons we know today debuted a few years later, in 1927. Imagine wrangling elephants down Broadway now!
What's the deal with Canada's Thanksgiving?
Canada celebrates Thanksgiving too, but earlier – the second Monday in October. Its roots are different, tied more to European harvest festivals and later, celebrations of safe journeys and military victories. Martin Frobisher's 1578 voyage is often cited as an early Canadian thanksgiving event. Their feast is similar (turkey, etc.), but without the Pilgrim narrative or the Black Friday frenzy.
How much turkey do Americans actually eat on Thanksgiving?
It's a massive amount! Estimates consistently put it between **45-46 million turkeys** consumed for Thanksgiving in the US each year. That's a whole lot of birds. Hope they had a good life.
Is Thanksgiving celebrated outside the US and Canada?
Not as a widespread national holiday rooted in North American history like it is here. Other countries obviously have harvest festivals or days of thanksgiving, but they are distinct traditions (like Germany's Erntedankfest). American expats might celebrate it abroad, bringing the tradition with them.
Why is there controversy around Thanksgiving?
The controversy stems from the gap between the simplified, often mythologized "Pilgrims and Indians" story taught for generations and the harsh historical realities of colonization. For many Indigenous peoples, the arrival of Europeans marked the beginning of catastrophic loss and oppression. Celebrating only the 1621 feast without acknowledging the devastating consequences that followed feels like erasure to them. It's about confronting the full, complex history.
How can I learn more about the Wampanoag perspective?
Excellent question! Seek out sources from the Wampanoag people themselves. The website of the **Wampanoag Tribe of Gay Head (Aquinnah)** and the **Plimoth Patuxet Museums** (formerly Plimoth Plantation), which works closely with tribal advisors, offer authentic perspectives. Look for books and documentaries created by Native scholars and communities. It's essential listening.
Wrapping It Up: More Than Just a Meal
Tracing the long, winding path of the thanksgiving history of the United States reveals a holiday far richer and more intricate than the grade-school pageant version. It's a tapestry woven from threads of survival, religious observance, political maneuvering (thanks, FDR!), savvy marketing, evolving traditions, and yes, deep cultural conflict and resilience.
The core idea – taking a day to pause and reflect on gratitude – is undeniably powerful and resonates across cultures. Understanding the full weight of the history, the messy origins, the painful truths alongside the cherished traditions, allows us to observe Thanksgiving with greater depth, respect, and perhaps, a more meaningful sense of gratitude. It’s not about canceling the turkey dinner; it’s about enriching our understanding of why we gather and acknowledging all the stories that brought us here.
So this November, when you sit down (or collapse after cooking!), maybe take a moment before digging in. Think about the long journey, the real people involved centuries ago, the complex legacy, and the simple, profound act of being thankful. Pass the gravy... and the understanding.
Comment