Let's be honest. Interviewing candidates feels draining sometimes. You're juggling calendars, reviewing resumes, and hoping this next person won't be another bad hire that costs your team months of headaches. The magic bullet? Asking the right questions to ask by an interviewer. Not the generic "What's your biggest weakness?" nonsense that gets rehearsed answers.
I remember interviewing someone for a marketing role years ago. Looked great on paper, nailed the standard questions. But I decided to throw in a curveball: "Walk me through how you'd explain our complex SaaS product to my 70-year-old grandma." Blank stare. Then jargon. That question exposed more about their actual communication skills than anything else.
That's what this guide is about. Moving beyond the script. We're diving deep into the questions for the interviewer that actually reveal competence, culture fit, and potential. The kind that help you sleep at night knowing you hired someone solid.
Why Your Current Questions to Ask as an Interviewer Might Be Failing
Most interviewers wing it. They recycle the same old questions everyone uses. The result? You get polished, practiced answers that sound good but tell you nothing real. It's like judging a car solely by its shiny paint job.
Bad hires are expensive. Like, "20-30% of their annual salary" expensive according to most HR studies. Ouch. Worse, they tank team morale. Ever worked with someone who just didn't gel? It's brutal.
The fix isn't more questions. It's better questions to ask during an interview by you, the person who needs a teammate, not just a warm body.
The Core Goals of Killer Interview Questions
Your questions should aim to uncover:
- Real Skills: Can they actually *do* the job? Not just talk about it.
- Problem-Solving: How do they think when things get messy?
- Cultural Fit: Will they thrive here, or just survive?
- Motivation: Why are they *really* looking? Money? Growth? Escape?
- Self-Awareness: Do they know their strengths and where they stumble?
The Interviewer's Toolkit: Questions Phased Like a Pro
Think of interviewing in phases. You wouldn't ask about salary expectations in the first 5 minutes (please tell me you wouldn't!). Structure matters.
Stage 1: Screening Call (The Filter)
Goal: Quickly weed out obvious mismatches. Keep it tight.
| Question Category | Specific Questions to Ask as Interviewer | What You're Really Probing | Red Flag Answers |
|---|---|---|---|
| Role Understanding | "Based on the job description, what part of this role excites you most, and what part seems like it might be a stretch?" | Did they actually read it? Realistic self-assessment? | Vague answers, enthusiasm for irrelevant parts, ignoring the "stretch" part. |
| Basic Logistics | "This role requires being in the office Tuesday/Thursday for team collaboration. Does that align with your expectations?" | Deal-breaker alignment. Saves everyone time. | Hesitation, immediate negotiation for fully remote. |
| Core Competency Sniff Test | "What's one tool/technique you used recently in [Key Skill Area, e.g., project management] that made a difference?" | Practical application, not just theory. | Generic answers ("I'm organized"), can't name a specific tool/action. |
Don't waste 30 minutes here. 15 is plenty if you ask sharp questions for interviewer screening.
Stage 2: The Deep Dive (Competency & Problem Solving)
This is where most interviews live. It's also where generic questions fail hardest. Ditch the hypotheticals. Demand specifics.
My Golden Rule: Always ask for a specific example from their recent past. "Tell me about a time..." is your anchor.
| Skill Area | Strong Questions to Ask by Interviewer | Weak Questions (Avoid These!) |
|---|---|---|
| Problem Solving | "Tell me about a complex work problem you solved recently. Walk me through the steps you took, how you identified the root cause, and what the outcome was." (Listen for process, not just result) | "Are you a good problem solver?" (Everyone says yes) |
| Teamwork/Conflict | "Give me an example of a time you disagreed with a colleague or manager on an approach. How did you handle it? What was the result?" | "Do you work well with others?" (Meaningless) |
| Adaptability | "Describe a situation where your priorities changed suddenly. How did you adjust your work? What was challenging?" | "Can you handle change?" (Again, yes) |
| Ownership/Initiative | "Tell me about something you spotted that needed improvement – beyond your core duties – that you took action on. What did you do?" | "Are you proactive?" (Yawn) |
See the difference? The good questions to ask by an interviewer force concrete evidence. You're not asking *if* they can do it, you're asking *how* they've done it before.
Dig deeper with follow-ups:
"What was your specific role in that project outcome?"
"Looking back, what would you do differently now?"
"What data or feedback told you that solution worked?"
Stage 3: Culture Fit & Motivation (The Hidden Make-or-Break)
Skills get them in the door. Fit determines if they stay and thrive. Motivation tells you if they'll stick around. This is where many interviewers drop the ball.
Warning: Don't confuse "culture fit" with "are they exactly like me?" It's about alignment with core values and work styles essential for success *in this specific role/team*.
Essential questions for the interviewer to uncover fit and drive:
- Work Style: "Describe the work environment or management style where you've done your best work. What made it successful for you?" (Compare to your reality)
- Feedback: "Tell me about a time you received difficult feedback. How did you process it? What did you do next?" (Crucial for growth!)
- Values Alignment: "What's one thing you really valued about your last company's culture? And one thing you found frustrating?"
- The Real 'Why': "What specifically about *this* role and *our* company interests you, beyond the job title?" (Beware generic "growth opportunity" answers)
- The Deal-Breaker Question: "What would make you decline an offer if we made one?" (Surprisingly revealing!)
Stage 4: Closing & Candidate Questions (Don't Screw Up the Finish)
Too many interviews end with a weak "Do you have any questions for us?" and that's it. Big mistake. This is still part of your assessment!
- Assess Their Questions: The questions *they* ask reveal their priorities. Are they asking about growth? Team dynamics? Impact? Or just vacation policy and free snacks?
- Selling (Realistically): "Based on our conversation, what's your biggest hesitation about this role or our company?" Address it honestly.
- Next Steps Clearly: "What does your ideal timeline look like?" and "What other roles are you actively considering?" (Gauges urgency/competition)
Skipping these questions to ask by an interviewer at the closing stage leaves you guessing.
Advanced Tactics: Questions Interviewers Often Forget (But Shouldn't)
Want to really stand out? Level up with these often-overlooked gems.
Structured Reference Checks (Yes, Ask Questions!)
Don't just verify employment. Ask references targeted questions for interviewer insights:
- "Can you describe a specific project where [Candidate] really excelled? What was their key contribution?"
- "What type of management style brings out their best work?"
- "If you had the opportunity to hire them again, would you? Why or why not?" (Silence or hesitation speaks volumes)
- "What's one area they genuinely needed to focus on for development?"
Projecting Future Performance: The "Case Study Lite"
For critical roles, pose a brief, realistic scenario related to your actual work:
"Imagine you started this role. In your first month, you discover [Relevant Challenge, e.g., low user engagement with feature X]. What steps would you take to understand the issue and start addressing it?"
Listen for their process, questions, and how they frame the problem.
Diversity, Equity & Inclusion (Beyond Box-Ticking)
Ask about real experience and understanding:
- "Tell me about a time you worked on a team with diverse perspectives. How did that impact the work?"
- "How do you approach creating inclusive environments in your day-to-day work?"
- "What does psychological safety mean to you in a team context?"
These questions to ask during an interview reveal much more than a checkbox.
What NOT to Ask: Legal Landmines for Interviewers
This is critical. Asking illegal questions opens you and your company to massive liability. Steer clear of anything related to:
- Age: (When did you graduate? How old are your kids?)
- Family Status: (Are you married? Planning to have children?)
- Religion/National Origin: (Where were you born? What holidays do you observe?)
- Disability/Health: (Do you have any health issues? Ever filed workers' comp?)
- Arrest Record: (Have you ever been arrested?) (Convictions relevant to the job may be asked later, carefully)
Seriously: Stick strictly to questions about skills, experience, and ability to perform the core job functions. If you're unsure if a question is legal, DON'T ASK IT. Consult HR or legal. This isn't just about being nice; it's about compliance.
Putting It All Together: Your Interview Question Bank
Here's a categorized cheat sheet of core questions to ask by an interviewer covering all phases. Mix and match based on the role.
| Category | Essential Questions to Ask as Interviewer |
|---|---|
| Role Understanding & Motivation |
|
| Skills & Experience (STAR Focus) |
|
| Problem Solving & Initiative |
|
| Teamwork & Collaboration |
|
| Work Style & Culture Fit |
|
| Looking Forward & Closing |
|
This bank gives you the core questions for interviewer success. Tailor them!
Beyond the Questions: Making Your Interviews Actually Work
Asking the right questions to ask by an interviewer is only half the battle. Execution matters.
- Listen More, Talk Less: Aim for 80/20 (candidate talking/interviewer talking). Your job is to probe, not lecture.
- Take Notes (Structured): Use your question categories. Note specifics ("mentioned tool X for project Y"), not just "good answer".
- Calibration is Key: If multiple people interview, agree on core competencies and sample questions upfront. Avoid lone wolves scoring differently.
- Scorecards Suck (But Use Them Anyway): Define clear ratings for each competency *before* interviews start (e.g., "Exceeds", "Meets", "Below"). Gut feelings are unreliable. Base it on evidence from their answers to your questions to ask during an interview.
Common Interviewer Dilemmas (Answered)
"The candidate rambles! How do I get them back on track?"
Politely interrupt: "Thanks for that background. To focus on [Specific Part Needed], could you tell me more about how you specifically handled [X]?" Guide them to the STAR nugget.
"They give short, unhelpful answers. How do I dig deeper?"
Ask follow-ups relentlessly: "Interesting. Could you give me a specific example of when that happened?" "What was your exact role in that outcome?" "What happened next?" "How did you feel about that result?"
"They ask about salary way too early. What do I do?"
Deflect gracefully: "We're still evaluating fit and skills for the role at this stage. We'll be happy to discuss compensation specifics once we determine mutual interest and potential fit. For now, does the range mentioned in the job posting align with your expectations?" Gets you a yes/no without committing.
"How many 'interviewer questions to ask' is too many?"
It's about quality and depth, not quantity. For a 60-minute interview, 5-7 core competency questions (with follow-ups) plus a few motivation/fit questions is usually ample. Rushing through 20 questions is pointless.
"What if their answer seems rehearsed?"
Push for specifics they can't fake: "That's a common challenge. In *that specific example* you mentioned, what was the *first* concrete step you took?" or "What unexpected obstacle came up during that project?" Real experience has texture.
Final Thoughts: Ditch the Script, Hire the Human
Great interviewing isn't about having a secret list of perfect questions to ask by an interviewer. It's about curiosity. It's about peeling back the layers to find the real person and how they'll actually show up on your team.
Stop asking questions that anyone can Google the "right" answer to. Start asking questions that demand proof, reveal thinking, and expose genuine motivations. It takes more effort upfront, sure. But compare that to the soul-crushing effort of managing a bad hire. Trust me, it's worth it.
What's the one question you've found most revealing? I'd love to hear yours.
Comment