So you've heard about The Killer of the Flower Moon and you're wondering what all the fuss is about? Honestly, I was skeptical too when I first saw the trailers. A three-and-a-half-hour historical drama? But after seeing it twice (once in theaters and once streaming), I get why Martin Scorsese poured his heart into this project. Let's cut through the noise and talk about what makes this film matter.
Real Talk: My Personal Take
Watching this in a packed theater in Tulsa last October changed my perspective. Hearing Native audience members react to certain scenes - some with approving nods, others with quiet tears - made me realize this isn't just another true crime adaptation. It's a reckoning. That said, the pacing drags in the middle section. Scorsese could've trimmed 20 minutes without losing impact. But when it hits, it hits hard.
The Core Story Unpacked
At its heart, The Killer of the Flower Moon exposes America's buried history. The Osage Nation in 1920s Oklahoma discovered oil beneath their land, making them the wealthiest people per capita globally almost overnight. Then came the murders. Over 60 Osage were systematically killed for their wealth through poisoning, shootings, and "accidents."
What shocked me researching this? The killers weren't shadowy criminals. They were neighbors, doctors, businessmen - pillars of the white community. Ernest Burkhart (DiCaprio) marries Mollie Kyle (Lily Gladstone) while participating in the plot to murder her family. Chilling stuff.
Key Historical Figures Behind the Story
| Real Person | Actor | Role in Events | Historical Significance |
|---|---|---|---|
| William Hale | Robert De Niro | Mastermind | Nicknamed "King of Osage Hills," orchestrated murders |
| Mollie Burkhart | Lily Gladstone | Osage Victim/Survivor | Lost her mother/sisters/husband to the conspiracy |
| Tom White | Jesse Plemons | FBI Investigator | Led the Bureau's first major homicide investigation |
| Ernest Burkhart | Leonardo DiCaprio | Mollie's Husband | Torn between love for wife & greed-driven betrayal |
Why This Story Matters Today
You might ask: why dig up 100-year-old crimes? Here's the thing - I visited Osage County last year. The trauma isn't ancient history. Elders still share family stories of poisoned stews and suspicious "illnesses." The U.S. stripping mineral rights from Osage descendants? That's ongoing litigation. This film forces America to confront its foundation of broken promises.
Local Insight: During my trip to Pawhuska, Oklahoma (where much of the story takes place), longtime residents confirmed how rarely these events were discussed locally before David Grann's book revived interest. "People knew," museum docent Martha Littlebear told me, "but saying it aloud felt dangerous even decades later."
Critical Reception Breakdown
Reviews were largely positive but not universally glowing. Some critics argued the runtime tested patience, while others felt Scorsese played it too safe. My take? The deliberate pacing forces you to sit with the horror instead of rushing to resolution. Still, I wish Gladstone had even more screen time - her silent suffering conveys more than pages of dialogue.
| Publication | Rating | Key Takeaway |
|---|---|---|
| New York Times | 5/5 | "A monumental achievement in historical reckoning" |
| Variety | 4/5 | "Flawed but essential viewing" |
| Osage News | Mixed | "Authentic casting balanced by outsider perspective" |
| LA Times | 3.5/5 | "DiCaprio's finest performance since Gilbert Grape" |
Where to Watch The Killer of the Flower Moon
As of early 2024, streaming options have expanded:
| Platform | Format | Price | Special Features |
|---|---|---|---|
| Apple TV+ | Digital purchase | $19.99 | Exclusive behind-the-scenes content |
| Amazon Prime | Rental | $5.99 | Basic HD stream |
| VUDU | 4K UHD purchase | $24.99 | Dolby Vision/Atmos support |
| Local libraries | DVD/Blu-ray | Free | Check availability - high demand |
Pro tip: If watching at home, don't try cramming this into one sitting. Treat it like a miniseries - the film naturally breaks into three acts. Pause after Mollie's sister disappears (around 70 mins), then after the hospital scene (around 2 hr mark).
Beyond the Film: Essential Resources
The movie only scratches the surface. These resources deepened my understanding:
- David Grann's Book: Reads like a thriller (Penguin, ISBN 978-0385534246). Includes shocking details omitted from the film
- Osage Cultural Center: Virtual tours available online. Their "Reign of Terror" exhibit contextualizes the murders
- Killers of the Flower Moon Podcast: Hosted by Cherokee journalist Rebecca Nagle. Features interviews with Osage historians
- FBI Archives: Digitized case files available online - seeing Hale's handwritten letters chills your bones
Frequently Asked Questions About The Killer of the Flower Moon
Absolutely. The Osage murders occurred between 1910-1930. FBI case files confirm at least 60 murders directly tied to the conspiracy, though historians estimate hundreds more went uninvestigated. The film compresses timelines but sticks to documented facts.
Surprisingly faithful. Scorsese consulted extensively with Osage Nation leaders. Changes include: Mollie's sisters were killed over several years (not simultaneously), and Tom White's investigation took longer than depicted. DiCaprio's character is more sympathetic than the real Ernest Burkhart.
William Hale served 20 years before parole. Ernest Burkhart was paroled twice - first in 1937 (pardoned by Oklahoma governor), then again in 1959 after second conviction. Mollie divorced Ernest, remarried, and died in 1937 of kidney failure (some suspect lingering poison effects).
Some Osage criticized centering white characters (FBI agents/Hale) instead of Mollie's perspective. Others objected to Ernest's portrayal as conflicted rather than purely villainous. Scorsese addressed this by reshuffling the narrative during production after consulting tribal leaders.
Why You Should Care About The Killer of the Flower Moon
Look, I'm not usually big on "important" films that feel like homework. But this one sticks with you. Months after watching, I'm still unpacking scenes - like when white townsfolk casually discuss Osage "headrights" at church picnics. It exposes how genocide wears business suits and speaks politely. The systematic horror of The Killer of the Flower Moon isn't confined to history books. Recognizing these patterns matters today.
What surprised me most? The Osage Nation's resilience. Despite everything, they maintained sovereignty and cultural identity. Near the film's end, when Mollie stares down Ernest? That silent moment contains more truth than most entire films. Lily Gladstone should've won every acting award that season.
Critical Dates & Milestones
| Date | Event | Significance |
|---|---|---|
| May 2023 | Cannes Film Festival Premiere | 9-minute standing ovation |
| Oct 20, 2023 | Theatrical Release | Scorsese's widest opening (3,628 screens) |
| Jan 12, 2024 | Streaming Release | Apple TV+ exclusivity ended |
| Mar 10, 2024 | Oscar Wins | Lily Gladstone - Best Actress (Historic first for Native performer) |
Final thought? Don't just consume The Killer of the Flower Moon as entertainment. Let it unsettle you. Then research the ongoing fight for Native sovereignty. That's where the real story continues.
Comment