Snapped a screw head clean off? Yeah, that sinking feeling when your driver spins uselessly and you see that little metal stump grinning back at you. Happened to me last summer rebuilding my deck - snapped three lag bolts in treated lumber. Wasted a whole Saturday before I figured it out. Getting a broken screw out feels impossible sometimes, but listen, it’s usually fixable without wrecking your project. You just need the right tricks and maybe a bit of patience (and maybe a cold drink).
Before You Fight That Stuck Screw: Gear Up Right
Grabbing pliers first? Stop right there. Trying to force it without prep usually makes things ten times worse – trust me, I’ve enlarged more holes than I care to admit. Getting this right depends hugely on what you do first.
What You Absolutely Need in Your Corner
- Safety glasses (Metal shards in the eye? No thanks)
- Sharp center punch (Essential for stopping drill bits skating)
- Variable speed drill (Corded often has more torque for this)
- Left-handed drill bits (Surprisingly magical sometimes)
- Quality screw extractor kit (Irwin, Grabit, or Alden usually work best)
- Rubber bands or valve grinding compound (For grip)
- Hammer
- Pliers (Vise-Grips lock better than slip-joint)
- Penetrating oil (PB Blaster beats WD-40 here)
- Sharp utility knife
- Dremel with cutting wheel (For creating new slots)
- Epoxy putty (J-B Weld SteelStik saved my deck project)
Warm the metal around the screw slightly with a heat gun if it’s stuck due to corrosion. Just enough to expand the metal slightly – don’t melt surrounding materials. Works wonders on old car parts.
Why Did Your Screw Break Anyway? Know Your Enemy
| Cause | What Happened | Common Fix Approach |
|---|---|---|
| Over-tightening | Snapped the head or shaft | Extractor or drilling out |
| Corrosion | Fused to the material | Penetrating oil, heat, extractor |
| Stripped Head | Driver spun, then head broke | Rubber band trick, slot cutting, pliers |
| Cheap Metal | Low-quality screw sheared | Often requires drilling/extractor |
| Wrong Driver Bit | Cam-out caused failure | Gripping methods first |
Your Battle Plan: Proven Ways to Get That Broken Screw Out
Okay, let’s get down to business. Not every trick works every time. Start simple and work up. Trying to drill immediately is like using a sledgehammer to crack a nut – sometimes needed, but messy.
When There's Still Something to Grab
The Rubber Band Trick: Jam a thick rubber band over the broken stub. Press your driver bit HARD into the rubber band covering the screw head remnant. Turn slowly counter-clockwise. Sounds dumb, worked on a cabinet hinge screw for me last week. Worth a shot first.
Upgrade Your Grip: Valve grinding compound (find it at auto parts stores) or even a sprinkle of coarse sand on the broken stub gives your pliers or driver bit insane bite. Slather some on the jaws of locking pliers (Vise-Grips are king), clamp down brutally tight, and twist gently.
Cut a New Slot: Got a Dremel? Use a thin abrasive cutoff wheel to carefully slice a straight slot across the top of the broken screw shaft. Now use a flathead screwdriver. Tap it gently with a hammer first to seat it. Turn slow and steady pressure. Use safety glasses!
When the Screw is Flush or Below the Surface
This is where the real fun begins. Getting a broken screw out buried in wood or metal is tougher.
Penetrating Oil is Your Friend: Soak the broken screw end liberally with PB Blaster, Liquid Wrench, or Kroil. Let it sit for hours, ideally overnight. Tap the screw lightly with a hammer a few times during soaking to help vibration work the oil in. Reapply. Heat gently with a heat gun if safe (not near fuel or wires!). This step alone loosened the most stubborn deck screw for me.
Center Punch & Left-Handed Drill Bits: This is step one before extractors. Use a sharp center punch and hammer to make a solid indent DEAD CENTER on the broken screw. Why? Because your drill bit WILL skate otherwise. Start with a small left-handed drill bit (they spin counter-clockwise). Chuck it in your drill on SLOW speed. Often, the drilling action alone grabs and unscrews the broken piece. If not, you've made a pilot hole for...
Screw Extractor Kits - Use Them Right or Fail: Don't just jam it in! Pick an extractor size slightly smaller than the screw shaft diameter. Drill the pilot hole using the recommended size bit from the kit instructions (usually smaller than the extractor itself). Tap the extractor firmly into the pilot hole with a hammer. Use a wrench or tap handle (NOT your drill!) on the extractor's square end. Turn SLOWLY and steadily counter-clockwise with downward pressure. Feel it bite? Keep going. If it snaps... well, now you have hardened steel stuck in there. Bad times. Choosing the right kit matters:
| Extractor Kit Type | Best For | Pros | Cons | My Pick |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Spiral Flute (Easy Out) | Most common broken screws | Widely available, multiple sizes | Can snap easily if forced | Irwin Hanson |
| Spiral Pro (Grabit) | Tough, stripped screws | Double-ended, biting rings grip hard | Requires precise pilot hole | Grabit Pro |
| Square Drive (Alden) | Extremely stuck or hardened screws | Less likely to cam out, strong | More expensive, needs tap handle | Alden 4500P |
The Drill-Out Method (Last Resort): If extraction fails, you drill out the entire screw. This risks damaging the surrounding material. Start by drilling a small pilot hole dead center using a cobalt or titanium bit HARDER than the screw. Gradually increase bit sizes until you drill out the screw shank. Go slow, use cutting oil on metal, stop frequently to clear chips. In wood, you can plug the hole later. In metal, you might need to re-tap the hole.
Warning: Drilling hardened steel extractors is a nightmare. If you snap an extractor off inside the screw, STOP. You likely need professional EDM (Electrical Discharge Machining) removal. This is expensive. Better to avoid snapping it in the first place by using steady pressure, not brute force!
Desperate Times, Desperate Measures
Stuck with a broken screw in a critical spot and nothing else worked? Consider these:
- Weld a Nut: If you have access to a welder (even a small MIG), carefully weld a nut onto the top of the broken screw stub. Let it cool slightly, then wrench it out. Works brilliantly on vehicle parts if you can access it safely.
- Epoxy Bonding: Clean the broken screw stub and the INSIDE of a small socket thoroughly with acetone. Mix a tough epoxy putty like J-B Weld SteelStik. Jam it into the socket and press firmly onto the screw stub. Hold it perfectly still until cured rock solid (follow epoxy time). Attach a wrench to the socket and turn.
Material Matters: Wood vs. Metal vs. Drywall
Your approach changes depending on what the screw broke off in.
How to Get a Broken Screw Out of Wood
Generally easier. Corrosion is less likely.
- Pliers/Gripping Methods First: Often works if any stump protrudes.
- Extractors Work Well: Pilot hole drilling is usually straightforward in wood.
- Drill Out and Plug: Low risk. Drill out, then glue in a wooden dowel or plug. Sand flush. I keep hardwood dowels and plug cutters for this.
- Break Out Carefully: For screws near an edge, sometimes you can carefully chisel out a small section of wood around the screw to expose enough to grip.
How to Get a Broken Screw Out of Metal
Tougher. Corrosion is the killer.
- Penetrating Oil and Heat are Crucial: Don't skip the soak time.
- Left-Handed Bits & Extractors: Primary methods. Center punching is vital.
- Welding a Nut: Often the best solution for badly stuck broken screws in steel.
- Drilling Out Requires Care: Use sharp cobalt bits, cutting oil, and slow speeds to avoid work-hardening the metal. You'll likely need to re-tap the hole.
How to Get a Broken Screw Out of Drywall/Plaster
Usually, the screw breaks because it hit something solid behind the wall.
- Pulling is Better Than Turning: If any stub sticks out, use locking pliers to pull it straight out, not twist.
- Push it In: If it's an anchor screw and broken flush, carefully push the whole anchor assembly deeper into the wall cavity. Patch the hole. Often the easiest solution.
- Cut Around It: Use a utility knife to carefully cut a small circle of drywall around the broken screw. Remove the plug, extract the screw from the plug with pliers, then patch the hole. Messier but effective.
Stop Breaking Screws! Prevention is Way Easier
Let's be honest, learning how to get a broken screw out is useful, but not breaking them is better. Here’s how to avoid the headache:
- Don't Buy Trash Screws: Cheap zinc-plated screws from big boxes snap easily. Spend a bit more on hardened steel or quality brands like GRK, Spax, or deck screws rated for the job.
- Pilot Holes are Mandatory: Especially in hardwoods or near edges. The pilot hole diameter should be roughly the screw shaft diameter minus the threads. Lubricate the screw threads with soap or wax.
- Use the Correct Driver Bit Size and Type: A worn or ill-fitting bit causes cam-out, stripping the head and leading to breaks. Phillips #2 isn't always PH#2 – look for JIS (Japanese Standard) if working on Japanese gear. Torx (star) bits offer far better grip.
- Drill Speed & Pressure: High speed generates heat, softening metal. Use moderate speed and steady, firm pressure. Let the drill do the work.
- Know When to Stop: Feel the resistance increase significantly? Stop. Don't force the last quarter turn if it's fighting you. Back it out slightly, check alignment, try again.
Got Questions? Broken Screw Removal FAQ
Will heating a broken screw help loosen it?
Yes, but carefully! Heat causes metal to expand slightly. Heating the SURROUNDING metal (not necessarily the screw directly) can break the bond of corrosion or thread lock. Use a heat gun, not an open flame (especially near flammable stuff!). Heat gently, then try your removal method. Don't overheat aluminum or thin materials.
Is WD-40 good for removing broken screws?
Honestly? WD-40 is okay as a water displacer and light lubricant, but it sucks as a penetrating oil for seriously stuck screws. PB Blaster, Liquid Wrench, Kroil, or even a 50/50 acetone and ATF (automatic transmission fluid) mix work way better. Use the good stuff for broken screw removal.
Can I use a screw extractor on really small broken screws?
It's tricky. Standard extractor kits often start around #4 or #6 screw sizes. For tiny screws (like eyeglasses or electronics), specialized micro extractor sets exist, but they're fragile. Sometimes, supergluing a tiny bit or even a precision-ground flathead into a slot cut with a razor saw is the only way. Requires surgeon hands.
What's the biggest mistake people make trying to get a broken screw out?
Rushing and forcing it. Jumping straight to drilling without centering. Using the wrong size extractor or drill bit. Not using penetrating oil or heat when corrosion is likely. And the cardinal sin? Not wearing safety glasses. Drill bits and extractors snap, metal flies.
Is it worth trying to remove a broken screw, or should I just leave it?
Depends. If it's critical for structure (like deck railing), affects function, or is in a spot where you need a hole, you gotta remove it. If it's cosmetic, hidden, and not causing an issue? Sometimes the battle scars aren't worth it. Plugging the hole or working around it might be smarter. I've left a few buried in non-critical spots.
Wrapping Up the Broken Screw Battle
Figuring out how to get a broken screw out feels like a victory when it finally spins free. The key is staying calm, assessing the situation (material, screw location, why it broke), and methodically working through the options from least destructive to most. Always start with penetrating oil and cleaning. Try gripping methods first if possible. Master the center punch and left-handed bits. Invest in a decent extractor kit and know how to use it properly. Drill-out is truly the last resort.
Remember:
- Patience and preparation beat brute force every time.
- The right tools (penetrating oil, punch, LH bits, good extractor) make all the difference.
- Safety glasses are non-negotiable.
- Preventing the break in the first place (good screws, pilot holes, correct bit, proper technique) saves you hours of frustration.
Next time you're facing that infuriating little metal stump, breathe deep, grab your tools, and show it who’s boss. You've got this.
Comment