So you're planning a trip to St John? Smart move. As someone who's been traveling there since 2010 – and made every accommodation mistake possible – I wish I'd had this guide back then. Let's cut through the fluff and talk straight about where to stay in St John.
First reality check: This ain't your typical Caribbean island. Two-thirds of it is national park land. No airports. No cruise ship docks. Just you, those insane turquoise bays, and wild donkeys wandering the roads. That's why picking your base matters way more than in most destinations.
Quick truth bomb: If you book a place without understanding the neighborhoods, you might spend half your vacation driving switchback roads. I learned that the hard way when I stayed at Coral Bay without renting a 4x4. Let's just say... I got very intimate with hitchhiking.
Breaking Down St John's Neighborhoods
Forget fancy marketing terms. Here's the real deal on each area:
Cruz Bay: The Hub
Where the ferry drops you off. Think of this as downtown St John – if "downtown" means colorful buildings, beach bars, and a grocery store that sells both organic kale and fishing tackle. You'll find:
- Walkability score: 9/10 – everything's within 15 minutes on foot
- Vibe: Lively but not crazy, great for people-watching
- Downside: Limited beachfront options, can hear bar music until midnight
My favorite memory here? Waking up at Gallows Point and swimming before breakfast while cruise ship day-trippers hadn't arrived yet. Magic.
Coral Bay: The Funky Side
Cross the island (about 20-30 mins drive) and you'll hit the "other side." More chickens than people. Fewer paved roads. The kind of place where restaurants close randomly because the chef went fishing.
Stayed here in 2018. Loved the stars at night – hated the drive back after dinner. If you're coming for peace? Epic. If you want convenience? Reconsider.
North Shore: Postcard Central
This stretch between Cruz Bay and Maho Bay is where you'll find those famous beaches like Trunk Bay and Cinnamon Bay. Views? Unreal. Practicality? Tricky.
True story: Friends rented a villa here last year. Spent $400/night for ocean views... then $75/day on taxis because walking anywhere wasn't happening. Balance is key.
South Shore & East End
Quieter beaches like Salt Pond Bay. Fewer amenities but total isolation if that's your jam. Saw the Milky Way so clearly out here it felt fake.
| Neighborhood | Best For | Avg. Rental Price | Car Needed? | My Rating |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Cruz Bay | First-timers, nightlife lovers | $250-$450/night | Optional | ★★★★☆ |
| Coral Bay | Return visitors, solitude seekers | $200-$350/night | Mandatory | ★★★☆☆ |
| North Shore | Beach obsessives, view hunters | $300-$800/night | Mandatory | ★★★★★ |
| South Shore/East End | Off-grid adventurers | $175-$300/night | Mandatory | ★★★☆☆ |
Accommodation Types: No BS Breakdown
Luxury Resorts & Villas
The Westin St John Resort Villas is the big player. Think pools, kids' clubs, and reliable AC. Good if you want predictability. Bad if you hate sharing space with conference groups.
Estate Lindholm is my personal splurge spot. Adults-only with views over Cruz Bay. Hot tip: Book room #7 – private balcony facing the sunset. Worth every penny when celebrating our anniversary.
Mid-Range Condos & Guest Houses
This is St John's sweet spot. Try:
- Serendip Condos (Cruz Bay): Walkable, kitchens, pool. Basic but clean. Like a friend's nice apartment.
- Coconut Coast Villas (near Cruz Bay): Where I stayed last June. Friendly owners, killer banana pancakes at their cafe downstairs.
Budget Options That Don't Suck
Yes, St John has hostels! St John Inn has rooms under $200 in summer. Tiny bathrooms but the patio has hammocks. Or camp at Cinnamon Bay – oceanfront sites for $40/night (book 6+ months ahead).
Reality Check: "Budget" here still means $150+/night. Saw a couple trying to Airbnb for under $100 – they ended up in someone's converted toolshed. Don't be them.
| Accommodation Type | Price Range | Booking Lead Time | Best Booking Site |
|---|---|---|---|
| Luxury Resorts | $400-$900/night | 6-8 months | Direct or Expedia |
| Private Villas | $300-$2000/night | 8-12 months | Vrbo or LuxuryRetreats |
| Condos/Guesthouses | $200-$400/night | 3-6 months | Booking.com |
| Budget Rooms/Camping | $40-$180/night | 2-4 months | Direct or ReserveAmerica |
Choosing Your Base: What They Don't Tell You
For Beach Hopping Fanatics
North Shore is your spot. You could literally wake up at Maho Bay (sea turtle central), have lunch at Cinnamon, and sunset at Hawksnest. Did this for a week once – water taxi costs added up but saved hours of driving.
Villa Rec: Grande Bay Residences. Steps from Cruz Bay but feels private. Rooftop hot tub sold me.
Families: Avoiding Meltdowns
Pick places near amenities:
- Cruz Bay: Near clinics if someone gets sea urchin spines (happened to my nephew)
- Westin Resort: Kid pools and organized activities
Skip the ultra-remote villas unless your kids love hour-long car rides.
Couples & Honeymooners
Seclusion matters. East End villas like Sirenusa have infinity pools looking toward the BVI. But here's the catch – that "romantic seclusion" means $25 sandwiches from the only deli within 10 miles. Pack snacks.
My Worst Pick Ever? That "charming hillside cottage" above Coral Bay. Photos showed ocean views – didn't show the 187 steps to reach it. Arrived with groceries in 90° heat... never again.
The Car Rental Dilemma
This affects where to stay more than you think:
- Cruz Bay: Skip the car if you'll mainly stay local. Parking costs $25/day
- Everywhere else: Non-negotiable. Book early – prices double last-minute
Essential tip: Rent from Cool Breeze or Courtesy. Avoid the airport agencies – their Jeeps couldn't handle Bordeaux Mountain road last rainy season. Saw two stuck tourists.
Transportation Costs (2024 Real Numbers)
| Option | Cost | Best For |
|---|---|---|
| Car Rental (Jeep) | $80-$120/day | Groups/families exploring daily |
| Safari Taxis | $5-$15 per person per ride | Short hops around Cruz Bay |
| Private Drivers | $50+/hour | Special occasions |
Booking Hacks I Learned the Hard Way
- Beware "cleaning fees": That $250/night villa? Add $250 cleaning + $200 service fee. Always calculate total cost
- Ask about mosquitos: Some valley locations get brutal at dusk. My Coral Bay rental provided zero screens – slept with Deet
- Check generator status: Power outages happen. Places without generators mean no AC in August. Sweltered through 3 days once
When to Book for Best Deals
| Season | Booking Timeline | Price Drop Potential |
|---|---|---|
| Peak (Dec-Apr) | 8-12 months early | 0-10% savings |
| Shoulder (May/Jun/Nov) | 4-6 months early | 15-25% savings |
| Low (Jul-Oct) | 1-2 months ahead | 30-50% savings (but risk hurricanes) |
Beyond the Bed: Location Perks
Where you stay determines your daily rhythm:
Food Scenes Near Bases
- Cruz Bay: 20+ restaurants. Try Longboard for tacos ($14), Morgan's Mango for upscale Caribbean
- Coral Bay: Skinny Legs burgers ($18) – cash only. Miss Lucy's Sunday jazz brunch
- North Shore: Mostly villa cooking. Starfish Market groceries cost 30% more than mainland
Activity Access
Snorkel gear rental spots cluster in Cruz Bay. Hiking trailheads? Mostly North Shore. If you're debating where to stay in St John based on activities:
- Best for divers: Coral Bay near East End dive sites
- Best for hikers: North Shore near Reef Bay Trail
- Best for boat charters: Cruz Bay marina pickups
Pro Tip: Book villas through management companies like Catered To or Vacation Vistas. Avoid random VRBO owners who might "forget" your booking. Happened to friends in 2022 – they got downgraded to a worse unit.
FAQs: Real Questions from Travelers
Is St John safe for solo travelers?
Safer than most Caribbean islands. Cruz Bay feels fine at night. Still, don't leave valuables on beaches – had my flip-flops stolen at Trunk Bay once. Seriously.
Can I stay without renting a car?
Only if based in Cruz Bay. Even then, you'll miss out. Taxis to Coral Bay cost $50+ each way. Group tours help but constrain you.
What's the minimum stay?
Most villas require 5-7 nights. Hotels might do 3. Camping allows 2+. Winter dates book fast – saw a villa owner turn down $10k for a 4-night request.
Are there all-inclusives?
Zero. Thank goodness. St John's charm is exploring local spots. If you want unlimited margaritas by a pool, try Mexico.
What about hurricane season?
July-October brings risk but lower prices. Get travel insurance that covers hurricanes. My September trip got evacuated – insurance paid for everything.
Is air conditioning essential?
YES. Don't believe "ocean breeze" listings. August heat is brutal. Places without AC should be 50% cheaper. Fought this battle with a host who claimed ceiling fans were adequate. They weren't.
Can I find last-minute deals?
Sometimes 30 days out on Booking.com. Risky during peak season. Friend scored a Westin villa for 40% off in May because of a cancellation.
Final Thoughts: Cutting Through the Noise
After 12 trips, here's my cheat sheet for deciding where to stay in St John:
- First trip? Cruz Bay condo or hotel. Minimize hassles
- Group of 6+? Private villa with pool. Split costs
- Honeymoon? North Shore luxury villa. Budget $600+/night
- Budget focus? Cruz Bay guesthouse or Cinnamon Bay camping
St John rewards planning. That couple arguing at the ferry dock about their "surprise hillside rental"? Don't be them. Think about your must-dos, tolerance for driving, and whether you need nightlife. Then book early – the good spots vanish.
Still debating where to stay in St John? Hit me on Instagram @StJohnInsider. I share villa finds and rental scams weekly. Because honestly? This island's too amazing to mess up your stay.
Comment