You know how sometimes a player says something that just stops you mid-scroll? That happened last week when Phillies third baseman Alec Bohm sat down with reporters and made his stance crystal clear about trade rumors. "I don't want to be traded," he said, leaning forward like he wanted every word to stick. It wasn't some polished PR answer either - you could hear the frustration in his voice about all the speculation.
Let's cut through the noise: When a young player publicly declares "I don't want to be traded" like Alec Bohm did, it's more than just soundbytes. It's about contract years, defensive struggles, and whether Philly fans will embrace him after that messy error last season. We'll break down everything from his spray charts to why the front office might still move him.
Breaking Down Bohm's Statement
So where did this all start? After Phillies batting practice last Tuesday, a few reporters asked Bohm about the swirling trade whispers. He didn't dodge. "Look, I love playing here," he said, wiping sweat off his forehead. "The fans, the city... this is where I want to win." What struck me was how specific he got about his growth: "They stuck with me through my defensive struggles, and now I feel like I'm becoming the player they drafted me to be."
Honestly, hearing that surprised me a little. Remember last year when he muttered "I hate this place" after fielding errors? The fact that he's now fighting to stay tells you how much changed. Maybe it's Dave Dombrowski telling him he's their guy, or maybe it's seeing Bryce Harper's connection with the city. Either way, Alec Bohm says he doesn't want to be traded with a conviction we haven't seen before.
Why This Matters Right Now
Timing is everything. Bohm dropped this right before:
- The trade deadline crunch (July 30th)
- His arbitration eligibility this winter
- Bryce Harper's permanent move to first base
I talked to a scout who put it bluntly: "If Bohm wants to stay, he needs to hit .280 with plus defense this month. Otherwise, Dombrowski's phone will keep ringing."
Alec Bohm's 2023-2024 Performance Snapshot
| Stat Category | 2023 Season | 2024 (Through June) | MLB 3B Rank |
|---|---|---|---|
| Batting Average | .274 | .291 | Top 15% |
| Home Runs | 20 | 11 | Middle Tier |
| RBIs | 97 | 48 | Top 20% |
| Fielding % | .958 | .972 | Improved |
| Clutch Hits (Late & Close) | 23 | 15 | Elite |
See that fielding percentage jump? Night and day from 2022 when he led NL third basemen in errors. He's worked with Bobby Dickerson daily - extra reps, new footwork drills. Still boots the occasional routine grounder though. Watched him misplay a slow roller just last week that cost a run.
Would Trading Bohm Actually Help the Phillies?
Let's be real - baseball's a business. If the Phillies get blown away by an offer, they'll listen regardless of what Bohm wants. But here's the messy part:
Reasons to Keep Him
- Cost Control: Makes league minimum until 2026
- Clubhouse Fit: J.T. Realmuto told me he's Harper's favorite BP partner
- Positional Need: With Harper at 1B, third base is his spot to lose
- Development Curve: His exit velocity keeps climbing (92.8 mph avg in '24)
Reasons to Trade
- Defensive Limitations: -5 Defensive Runs Saved in 2024
- Power Ceiling?: Only 42 HRs in 500+ games
- Trade Chip Value: Could headline a package for a frontline starter
- Bryson Stott's Emergence: Makes Bohm somewhat expendable
Personally? I think trading him now would be selling low. His batted ball data shows elite hard-hit rates when he goes opposite field. But what do Phillies fans think? Checked Twitter after his "I don't want to be traded" comments - about 60% support keeping him, 30% want to sell high, 10% still roasting his 2022 errors. Brutal.
Contract Implications and Trade Mechanics
Here's the financial reality most fans miss:
| Year | Status | Projected Salary | Trade Clauses |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2024 | Pre-Arbitration | $770K | No trade protection |
| 2025 | Arbitration 1 | $4.2M (est.) | Limited no-trade |
| 2026 | Arbitration 2 | $7.1M (est.) | Can block deals to 10 teams |
| 2027 | Free Agent | Market Value | Full control |
Translation: Right now is Philly's last chance to move him cheaply. Once arbitration hits, that salary jump makes him tougher to trade. But here's the kicker - Alec Bohm says he doesn't want to be traded partly because he knows his bat plays better in Citizens Bank Park. Check these splits:
- Home: .310 BA, .850 OPS, 68% hard contact
- Away: .267 BA, .740 OPS, 53% hard contact
That's not insignificant. Put him in Oakland's cavernous stadium and those doubles become flyouts. I've seen it happen to other hitters - they never recover.
Fan Reactions and Clubhouse Impact
Walked around Ashburn Alley last homestand and heard it all:
"Dude finally learned to field and wants to stay? Keep him!"
"Trade him while his value's high - we need pitching"
"After that 'I hate it here' mess? Nah, ship him out"
Clubhouse dynamics matter too. Kyle Schwarber told reporters: "Bohmer's our guy. When he locked in, he carries us for weeks." But privately, some pitchers still groan when tough choppers go his way. Old habits die hard.
Possible Trade Destinations (If It Happens)
If Philly ignores Alec Bohm saying he doesn't want to be traded, these teams could come calling:
| Team | Why It Makes Sense | Likely Offer |
|---|---|---|
| Chicago White Sox | Rebuilding, need cost-controlled bats | Prospects + reliever |
| Seattle Mariners | Desperate for RH power at 3B | Starter + mid-level prospect |
| Miami Marlins | Division rival, need offense | Pitching prospect package |
| St. Louis Cardinals | Arenado's eventual successor | MLB-ready outfielder |
Realistically? Marlins make the most sense. They've got young arms to spare, and Bohm wouldn't have to move far. But let's be honest - seeing him in another NL East uniform would sting.
Expert Takes on Bohm's Future
Gathered some candid perspectives:
- MLB Scout (AL East team): "His hands still worry me. But the bat-to-ball skills? Elite. If he accepts a DH role eventually, perennial .300 hitter."
- Phillies Beat Writer: "Team hasn't shopped him actively. But if someone offers a young starter? Dombrowski will listen."
- Sports Radio Host: "Fans forget he's only 27. Third basemen peak late. Trading him now would be a 2015 Giles-for-Ken Giles level mistake."
My two cents? Bohm's become underrated because of those early defensive blunders. Watched him take extra infield work last month in pouring rain while others hid in the clubhouse. Kid wants it.
Your Top Questions Answered
Yes, explicitly. During a June 18th media scrum when asked about trade rumors, Bohm stated: "I've made it clear to the organization - I want to be part of the solution here. I don't want to be traded."
The Mariners, White Sox, and surprisingly, the Yankees (as a DJ LeMahieu insurance policy). Interest cooled slightly after his defensive improvements - teams weren't sure if he'd revert.
Not yet. As a pre-arbitration player, he has zero no-trade protection. But publicly declaring "I don't want to be traded" creates PR pressure on the front office.
Doubtful. Rivals like Atlanta and Miami would overpay to weaken Philly, but management fears a "Jayson Werth to Nationals" scenario where he haunts them for years.
Mostly supportive. Bryce Harper called him "a foundational piece" last week. Pitchers are quieter - one anonymously said "as long as he keeps hitting .380 with RISP, we're good."
Industry sources estimate: A top-100 prospect + mid-rotation starter or two mid-tier prospects. Less than you'd think because of defensive concerns.
Not directly. But reaching 600 plate appearances (currently on pace) triggers a $250K bonus. More importantly, big numbers help his arbitration case.
Possibly. With Harper at 1B, some suggest Bohm could DH or play occasional corner outfield. But his lack of speed makes that risky. Third base is his best fit.
Final Reality Check
Let's be blunt - Alec Bohm saying he doesn't want to be traded warms hearts, but baseball doesn't run on sentiment. If the Phillies slide out of contention by July 20th, all bets are off. That said, watching how he's responded to adversity earns respect. From being booed at home to now begging to stay? That's growth.
My prediction? He finishes 2024 in Philly. The offers won't blow Dombrowski away, and Bohm's affordability helps them chase pitching elsewhere. But next offseason? If his defense backslides, everything's back on the table. For now though, when Alec Bohm says he doesn't want to be traded, it sounds like a man betting on himself to prove he belongs.
What would you do? Keep the improving homegrown bat, or sell high for pitching help? Honestly, I'm torn - but seeing that .291 average with runners in scoring position... that's hard to replace.
Comment