Okay, let's tackle this question that every football fan argues about at pubs, barbershops, and Twitter threads: who is the best soccer player in the world right now? I remember being in Madrid last year, watching a game at some cramped local bar, and this debate nearly caused a shouting match between two guys. One was waving his hands about Messi's World Cup, the other kept slamming his pint glass down yelling "Ronaldo's numbers!" Honestly? Both had points.
Here's the messy truth upfront: There's no single answer. What makes someone the "best" depends completely on what you value most. Are you looking at cold hard stats? Trophy cabinets? Pure magic with the ball? Leadership when it counts? We'll break down all these angles.
How We Measure Greatness (It's Not Just Goals)
If we just counted goals, this would be easy. But football's more complex. Let's look at what actually matters when judging the best soccer player in the world:
The Stat Sheet Stuff
• Goals & assists per game
• Key passes & chances created
• Successful dribbles
• Defensive contributions
• Passing accuracy
• Minutes per goal involvement
The Trophy Case
• League titles
• Continental cups (UCL)
• International trophies
• Ballon d'Or/Best FIFA awards
• Tournament MVPs
• Golden Boots
The Intangibles
• Clutch performances
• Leadership under pressure
• Game intelligence
• Versatility across positions
• Consistency over years
• Impact on team success
I once argued with my cousin for three hours about this. He only cared about stats. But then I saw Modric control a game without scoring - pure artistry. Stats don't capture that.
The 2023-24 Contenders: Breaking Down the Top Tier
Right now, these five names dominate the conversation about the current best soccer player in the world:
| Player | Club | Key Strengths | 2023 Key Stats | Trophy Case |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Lionel Messi | Inter Miami | Vision, dribbling, playmaking, free kicks | 28 G/A in 29 apps (2023) | 8 Ballons d'Or, WC, 4 UCL |
| Kylian Mbappé | PSG | Blistering speed, finishing, big-game mentality | 52 goals in 53 apps (club) | WC, 5 Ligue 1 titles |
| Erling Haaland | Man City | Physical dominance, positioning, ruthless finishing | 52 goals in 53 apps (2023) | UCL, Premier League Golden Boot |
| Kevin De Bruyne | Man City | Passing range, assists, game control | 18 assists in 32 apps | UCL, 5 PL titles, PFA POTY x2 |
| Vinicius Jr | Real Madrid | Dribbling, creativity, 1v1 ability | 23 G/A in 33 apps | UCL, La Liga, CDR |
Stats tell one story, but watching them play tells another. Haaland's like a shark smelling blood in the box - terrifying efficiency. But De Bruyne? He paints passes most players don't even see. Different flavors.
Messi vs. Ronaldo: Does the Debate Still Matter?
Let's address the elephant in the room. Even with Messi in Miami and Ronaldo in Saudi Arabia, their ghosts haunt this conversation. For 15 years, asking "who is the best soccer player in the world?" meant choosing between these two aliens.
Lionel Messi (Career)
• Goals: 821+
• Assists: 361+
• Ballons d'Or: 8
• Key Trophies: World Cup, Copa América, 4 UCL, 10+ league titles
• Unique Skill: Unreal close control, playmaking from deep
Watching him glide through defenses still feels unnatural. That 2022 World Cup performance? Pure legacy cement.
Cristiano Ronaldo (Career)
• Goals: 880+
• Assists: 250+
• Ballons d'Or: 5
• Key Trophies: Euros, 5 UCL, 7 league titles
• Unique Skill: Aerial dominance, relentless scoring instinct
His athletic prime was scary. Remember that bicycle kick against Juventus? Still gives me chills.
Personally, I think Messi sealed it with Argentina's World Cup win. But Ronaldo's longevity is insane - scoring buckets at 38. Both redefined excellence.
The Eye Test vs. The Spreadsheet
Numbers don't lie, but they don't tell the whole truth either. Here's where things get messy:
Example: You could watch Messi complete 12 dribbles and create 5 chances in a game he didn't score in. The spreadsheet shows zeros in the goal column. The eye test shows dominance.
Counter-example: Haaland might have 3 touches all game but score a hat-trick. Stats? Elite. Eye test? Invisible until lethal.
This is why folks argue. My buddy Dave says "football's about winning, not fancy flicks." Then I show him vintage Iniesta highlights and he shuts up for five minutes.
Position Matters: Can You Compare Strikers to Midfielders?
We often compare apples to oranges. How do you judge the best soccer player in the world when positions demand different skills?
| Position | Primary Metrics | 2023 Elite Examples | Why Comparison Is Tricky |
|---|---|---|---|
| Striker/Center Forward | Goals, shots on target, conversion rate | Haaland, Kane, Osimhen | Direct impact measurable by goals |
| Attacking Midfielder/Winger | Assists, chances created, dribbles, xGChain | Mbappé, Vinicius Jr, Saka | Creativity harder to quantify |
| Central Midfielder | Pass accuracy, progressive passes, tackles, interceptions | De Bruyne, Rodri, Bellingham | Defensive work often undervalued |
| Defender/Goalkeeper | Tackles, clearances, save percentage, clean sheets | Dias, Courtois, Hernández | Rarely considered for "best player" |
See the problem? A world-class defensive midfielder like Rodri might be more valuable to his team than a flashy winger. But we rarely call defenders the best soccer player in the world.
The New Generation: Who Could Claim the Throne?
While Messi and Ronaldo dominated for 15 years, these young guns are making their case:
Kylian Mbappé (24)
• Pace: 9.5/10
• Finishing: 9/10
• Big Moments: WC final hat-trick
• Needs: UCL with PSG
That World Cup final performance... kid's ice cold.
Erling Haaland (23)
• Goal Instinct: 10/10
• Physicality: 9.5/10
• Weakness: Link-up play
• Needs: Int'l trophies
Scoring feels inevitable when he's near the box.
Jude Bellingham (20)
• Maturity: freakish
• Box-to-box impact
• Leadership: 8.5/10
• Needs: Consistency
Watching him at Madrid this season? Absurd for 20.
But here's my hot take: Vinicius Jr gets underrated. His dribbling in tight spaces? Neymar-esque. If he adds consistent finishing, watch out.
Personal Bias Alert: What Fans Really Care About
Let's be honest - our preferences color everything. I'm a sucker for creative maestros. Give me a player who sees passes before anyone else. That's why I'll always lean toward Messi over pure scorers.
But I get why others disagree. My neighbor Sam, a former striker, values ruthless efficiency above all. "Why dribble past three when one touch does it?" he argues. Fair point.
Nationality plays a role too. Brazilians worship flair. Italians adore tactical intelligence. English fans love work rate. Our cultural lens shapes who we call the best soccer player in the world.
Frequently Asked Questions (The Pub Arguments)
Is Messi still the best after moving to MLS?
Statistically? No. But watch him play - the vision and technique remain elite. His World Cup performance secured his legacy. For current impact though, Europe-based players have the edge.
Why does Cristiano Ronaldo not make most current top 5 lists?
He's 38 playing in Saudi Arabia. While still scoring heavily, the competition level is lower. His peak years? Sure. But today? The conversation has moved on.
Can a defender ever be considered the best player in the world?
Theoretically yes, but it's unlikely. Attackers dominate eyeballs and awards. Paolo Maldini came closest in the 90s. Today? Maybe Ruben Dias on his best day, but he'd never win a Ballon d'Or.
Who has the strongest case for best player right now?
Between Haaland (stats monster) and Mbappé (big-stage brilliance). Haaland broke Premier League records. Mbappé dominated the World Cup. Edge to Mbappé for versatility and clutch genes.
Does the Ballon d'Or actually determine the best player?
Not really. It's heavily influenced by team trophies and narrative. Modrid won in 2018 without huge stats. Sneijder was robbed in 2010. Use it as one data point, not gospel.
The Bottom Line (My Take)
If you forced me to pick one name today? Mbappé. He combines Haaland's efficiency with Messi-esque dribbling and Ronaldo's big-game mentality. That World Cup final performance wasn't a fluke - it was a statement.
But ask me again after the Champions League knockout stages. Football changes fast. One magical performance can reshuffle the deck. That's why we love this endless debate about the best soccer player in the world - it never truly gets settled.
Maybe that's the point. Greatness isn't a title you hold forever. It's moments. That defense-splitting pass. That last-minute winner. That save when everything's on the line. Today's king is tomorrow's memory.
So who's the best? Right now, wear your Mbappé shirt with pride. But keep Haaland's number handy. And never count out the old magician in Miami when he decides to turn back time. The conversation continues...
Comment