So you wanna know when the Electoral College was created? Honestly, it's one of those things most Americans vaguely remember from high school civics class but can't quite pin down. Let me walk you through the whole story - no textbook jargon, just straight talk about how this system came to be and why it still matters today.
The Birth of the Electoral College: Summer of 1787
Picture this: Philadelphia, summer 1787. It's sweltering hot, delegates are arguing in a locked room with windows nailed shut (seriously, they did that to prevent eavesdropping). They're trying to build a new government from scratch. James Madison's taking notes, Benjamin Franklin's dropping wisdom bombs, and everyone's sweating through their wool coats.
Now here's where it gets interesting. The question of how to pick a president had them stumped. Direct popular vote? Big states would dominate. Let Congress choose? Too much power to legislators. After weeks of deadlock, they finally struck a compromise on September 6, 1787. That's the actual date when the Electoral College was created as part of the Constitution.
The Original Setup
What they cooked up was pretty clever for its time:
- Each state gets electors equal to their Congressional reps (Senators + House members)
- Electors cast two votes for president (no separate VP vote initially)
- Nobody serving in federal office could be an elector
- If no majority winner, the House decides with each state delegation getting one vote
Funny enough, the founders thought this would mostly be a nominating system and that most elections would end up decided in Congress. Shows how much they could predict!
Why Create This Weird System Anyway?
Let's be real - if you asked most folks today to design a voting system, nobody would invent something like the Electoral College. So why did they? Three big reasons:
Slavery and the Three-Fifths Compromise
This one's uncomfortable but crucial. Southern states had huge populations of enslaved people who couldn't vote. The compromise? Count 60% of slaves toward Congressional representation and electoral votes. More slaves = more political power. Without this, historians argue the Electoral College might never have been created at all.
Fear of Mob Rule
Alexander Hamilton straight up called the public "a great beast" in private letters. Most founders distrusted direct democracy. Roger Sherman captured the mood: "The people should have as little to do as may be about the government." The Electoral College acted as a buffer against what they saw as unpredictable masses.
The Small-State Protection Racket
Connecticut's Roger Sherman and Wisconsin's James Wilson (representing smaller states) insisted on protections against Virginia and New York dominating every election. The Electoral College gave smaller states disproportionate influence that continues today. Whether that's fair? Well...
Personal opinion incoming: I've always found it wild that Wyoming voters have nearly 4x the voting power of California voters in presidential elections. Feels like the founders' compromise went a bit too far in protecting small states, but hey, that's why they created the electoral college system.
How the Electoral College Changed Since 1787
The system created in 1787 barely resembles what we have today. Major tweaks:
| Year | Change | Impact |
|---|---|---|
| 1804 | 12th Amendment | After the 1800 tie disaster, electors now vote separately for President and VP |
| 1840s | States adopt winner-take-all | Instead of district voting, almost all states award all electors to statewide winner |
| 1876 | Electoral Count Act | Created rules for resolving disputed electors after the Hayes-Tilden mess |
| 1961 | 23rd Amendment | Gave Washington D.C. electoral votes (always 3) |
The Winner-Take-All Twist
Here's something they definitely didn't plan in 1787. Originally, most states split electors by congressional districts. But states realized they'd gain more national influence by awarding all electors to the statewide winner. Maryland started this in 1789, others followed like lemmings. Now only Maine and Nebraska split votes.
I remember talking to a Nebraska farmer who actually likes their district system. "Makes candidates care about more than just Omaha," he told me. Makes you wonder why more states don't try it.
Key Dates in Electoral College History
When people ask "when was the electoral college established," 1787 is just the starting point. Major moments:
- February 4, 1789: First presidential electors chosen (mostly by state legislatures)
- December 15, 1789: First electoral votes cast for Washington
- 1800: Tie between Jefferson and Burr triggers 12th Amendment
- 1824: "Corrupt bargain" election decided by House
- 1876: Disputed results in three states nearly cause civil war redux
- 2000: Bush vs. Gore decided by 537 votes in Florida
- 2016: Trump wins despite 2.8 million fewer popular votes
Modern Electoral College by the Numbers
How does the system created in 1787 function today? Let's break it down:
| Component | How It Works Today |
|---|---|
| Total Electors | 538 (435 Reps + 100 Senators + 3 for DC) |
| Winning Threshold | 270 electoral votes needed |
| Elector Selection | Chosen by state parties (mostly loyalists) |
| Voting Day | First Monday after second Wednesday in December |
| Faithless Electors | 33 states have laws against it (rarely enforced) |
Controversies That Just Won't Quit
Almost nobody's 100% happy with the system. Here's why:
The Popular Vote Problem
Five times now, presidents have taken office despite losing the nationwide popular vote. That's why folks question whether the electoral college creation date should be its expiration date. Defenders counter that it forces candidates to build national coalitions.
Swing State Dominance
You ever notice how candidates suddenly care about Ohio factory workers and Florida retirees every four years? Over 90% of campaign events happen in just 12 battleground states. If you live in California or Alabama, your vote basically doesn't register.
The Faithless Elector Wildcard
In 2016, seven electors broke ranks. Though it didn't change results, imagine if it happened in a tight race. Thirty-three states try to prevent this with penalties, but Supreme Court recently upheld their right to punish faithless votes.
A campaign staffer once told me about tracking electors like they were nuclear codes. "We had volunteers babysitting our electors on voting day," he laughed. Not sure if that's dedication or paranoia.
Could We Abolish the Electoral College?
Good luck with that. It would require a constitutional amendment needing 2/3 of Congress and 3/4 of states. Small states would never go for it. Clever workarounds exist though:
- National Popular Vote Compact: States pledge electors to national popular vote winner (already passed in 15 states + DC with 195 electoral votes)
- Ranked Choice Voting: Already used in Maine could reduce spoiler effect
- Proportional Allocation: More states adopting Maine/Nebraska model
Frequently Asked Questions
Could the Founding Fathers have imagined modern elections when the electoral college was established?
Not a chance. Considering they designed it before political parties existed and when news traveled by horseback, it's amazing the system works at all. Hamilton actually envisioned electors as wise deliberative bodies, not rubber stamps for party nominees.
Has anyone tried to change when the electoral college was created?
Over 700 proposed amendments to modify or abolish it since 1789! None came close except after the 1968 near-miss when George Wallace threatened to force a contingent election. Congress nearly passed a direct election amendment that failed by 6 votes.
What happens if the Electoral College deadlocks?
If no candidate gets 270 votes (like if a strong third party emerges), the newly elected House picks the president from the top three contenders. But here's the kicker - each state delegation gets ONE vote regardless of size. California (39 million people) and Wyoming (580,000) would have equal say. Wild, right?
When was the electoral college created relative to other democracies?
It's ancient. Most modern democracies created after 1945 use direct elections. Even countries like Germany that have similar systems (like for president) use them for ceremonial roles. America's basically the only country where the electoral college creation date determines actual executive power.
Do electors have to vote how their state did?
Technically no - 33 states try to bind them but penalties are weak ($1,000 fines in some places). Since 1796 there've been 165 "faithless electors" but none ever changed an election outcome. Still keeps election lawyers awake at night.
Why Does This 1787 System Still Matter?
However you feel about the electoral college, its creation changed everything. It determined:
- The structure of presidential campaigns (battleground state math)
- Which issues get attention (Iowa ethanol subsidies, Florida Medicare chatter)
- Whether third parties can survive (usually crushed by winner-take-all)
- The viability of different voting reforms (like ranked choice)
So when someone asks "when was the electoral college created," they're really asking about the DNA of American democracy. That hot Philadelphia summer in 1787 still shapes our politics in ways most voters don't even realize. Whether that's good or bad? Well, that's the debate that never ends.
Personally, after studying this for years, I think the system's showing its age. But replacing it would be like doing open-heart surgery on the Constitution. Maybe we'll see major changes after another disputed election. Or maybe we'll still be arguing about this in 2127. Either way, understanding when and why the electoral college was created is the first step to making sense of our messy, fascinating democracy.
Comment