So you've watched all eight Harry Potter films twenty times and can quote Dumbledore in your sleep. What now? That's where Harry Potter spin off movies come in. They're like discovering a secret room in Hogwarts – familiar magic but brand new adventures. I remember queueing for Fantastic Beasts and Where to Find Them back in 2016, butterbeer in hand, wondering if it could capture that old Potter magic. Let me walk you through everything about these extensions of J.K. Rowling's wizarding world.
What Counts as a Harry Potter Spin Off Movie Anyway?
When we talk about Harry Potter spin off movies, we mean films set in the same universe but not directly continuing Harry's story. They expand the lore, explore new characters, or dive into historical events mentioned in the original books. Some fans debate whether certain projects qualify, but here's the official lineup so far:
- The Fantastic Beasts series (three films released, two more planned)
- Hogwarts Legacy cinematic trailers (game promos with film-quality animation)
- Short films like Fantastic Beasts: A Natural History (BBC documentary hybrid)
Honestly? I was skeptical when they announced spin offs. Could Newt Scamander really carry a franchise like Harry did? But walking out of that first Fantastic Beasts screening, I had that same giddy feeling I got leaving Philosopher's Stone as a kid. Different but equally magical.
The Fantastic Beasts Trilogy: Full Breakdown
These are the heavy hitters when it comes to Harry Potter spin off movies. Set decades before Harry's birth, they mix magical creatures with dark wizard politics.
Fantastic Beasts and Where to Find Them (2016)
Release Date: November 18, 2016
Director: David Yates
Cast: Eddie Redmayne (Newt), Katherine Waterston (Tina), Dan Fogler (Jacob), Alison Sudol (Queenie), Colin Farrell (Graves)
Plot: Magizoologist Newt Scamander arrives in 1926 New York with a suitcase full of extraordinary creatures. When some escape, he teams up with unlikely allies while a sinister threat emerges.
Box Office: $814 million worldwide
Runtime: 133 minutes
Why it worked? The jazz-age wizarding America felt refreshing. The niffler scene in the bank? Pure joy. My sister still uses "niffler" as her password for everything.
Fantastic Beasts: The Crimes of Grindelwald (2018)
Release Date: November 16, 2018
Director: David Yates
Cast: Adds Jude Law (young Dumbledore), Johnny Depp (Grindelwald), Zoë Kravitz (Leta Lestrange)
Plot: Grindelwald escapes custody and recruits followers in Paris. Dumbledore recruits Newt to thwart him, forcing wizards to choose sides.
Box Office: $654 million worldwide
Runtime: 134 minutes
Let's be real – this one struggled. Too many subplots. That Credence twist felt forced. I actually dozed off during the Paris catacombs scene on my first watch. Needed tighter editing.
Fantastic Beasts: The Secrets of Dumbledore (2022)
Release Date: April 15, 2022
Director: David Yates
Cast: Mads Mikkelsen replaces Depp as Grindelwald
Plot: Dumbledore assembles Newt and allies to disrupt Grindelwald's election plans while confronting their past bond.
Box Office: $407 million worldwide
Runtime: 142 minutes
Mikkelsen saved this for me. His Grindelwald had chilling charisma. The Bhutan election sequence? Visually stunning. Still, why did Queenie's arc feel rushed?
| Film | Release Year | Rotten Tomatoes | IMDb Rating | Key Strengths | Common Criticisms |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Fantastic Beasts 1 | 2016 | 74% | 7.2/10 | Creature design, 1920s aesthetic | Slow second act |
| Crimes of Grindelwald | 2018 | 36% | 6.5/10 | Visual effects, Law's Dumbledore | Overstuffed plot, pacing issues |
| Secrets of Dumbledore | 2022 | 46% | 6.2/10 | Mikkelsen's performance, action sequences | Underdeveloped new characters |
Where to Watch These Harry Potter Spin Off Movies Right Now
Streaming availability changes constantly, but here's the current breakdown:
- HBO Max: All three Fantastic Beasts films in most regions
- Peacock: Rotating availability in the US
- Amazon Prime: Rent/Buy only ($3.99 rental, $14.99 purchase)
- Apple TV: Same as Prime pricing
- Sky Cinema/NOW: UK streaming hub
Pro tip: Check JustWatch.com before paying – I wasted £10 last month when Secrets of Dumbledore dropped on Max the next day.
Upcoming Harry Potter Spin Off Projects Confirmed
The Wizarding World isn't done expanding. Here's what's officially in development:
| Project | Expected Release | What We Know | Potential Impact |
|---|---|---|---|
| Fantastic Beasts 4 | 2025-2026? (Delayed) | Will focus on WWII era wizarding war | Could redeem franchise if scaled back |
| Fantastic Beasts 5 | TBD | Grindelwald's final showdown with Dumbledore | High stakes but audience fatigue risk |
| HBO Harry Potter Series | 2026+ | 10-year adaptation of original books | Massive - could reset entire franchise |
That HBO series announcement made my potterhead group chat explode last year. Faithful book adaptation? Yes please. But recasting iconic roles feels risky.
Rumor Mill: Insider leaks suggest a Marauders-era film (young Sirius/Lupin) being discussed. Not confirmed, but fansites are obsessively tracking this. Personally, I'd kill for that instead of more Fantastic Beasts.
Ranking the Existing Harry Potter Spin Off Movies
After multiple rewatches (yes, I timed my last marathon with a butterbeer tasting), here's my personal ranking:
- Fantastic Beasts 1 (2016)
- + Magical creature creativity
- + Jacob/Queenie chemistry
- - Weak villain reveal
- Secrets of Dumbledore (2022)
- + Mads Mikkelsen's layered Grindelwald
- + Dumbledore backstory payoff
- - Forgettable new characters (Lally? Who?)
- Crimes of Grindelwald (2018)
- + Stunning Paris visuals
- + Jude Law's charismatic Dumbledore
- - Confusing Nagini subplot
- - Overstuffed narrative
Controversial? Maybe. But Crimes of Grindelwald lost me with that Credence "twist." Felt like fanfiction gone wrong.
Why Do These Spin Offs Matter to Fans?
Beyond nostalgia trips, Harry Potter spin off movies serve crucial roles:
- World Expansion: Seeing Ilvermorny vs Hogwarts
- Historical Context: Understanding Voldemort's rise through Grindelwald's war
- Character Depth: Young Dumbledore's complexities
- Creature Lore: Those fantastic beasts textbooks come alive
Remember Dumbledore mentioning Grindelwald briefly in Deathly Hallows? These movies make that throwaway line feel monumental.
Common Complaints About Harry Potter Spin Off Movies
They're not perfect. Frequent fan grievances include:
- Pacing Issues: Second movies always sag (looking at you, Crimes of Grindelwald)
- Over-reliance on Nostalgia: Excessive Hogwarts cameos?
- Controversial Casting: Depp's personal issues affecting enjoyment
- Lore Inconsistencies: McGonagall appearing decades early?
My biggest gripe? The wasted potential of Queenie's descent into darkness. That could've been heartbreakingly powerful instead of rushed.
Frequently Asked Questions About Harry Potter Spin Off Movies
Are there Harry Potter spin off movies besides Fantastic Beasts?
Officially? Not yet. But the Hogwarts Legacy game trailers (especially the 4K cinematic ones) feel like short films. And that BBC Fantastic Beasts hybrid doc counts as expanded universe content.
Will there be more Harry Potter spin off movies after Fantastic Beasts?
Almost certainly. The HBO series is greenlit, and Warner Bros won't abandon this cash cow. Rumors persist about a Founders-era project or Azkaban prison series.
Why do fans argue about Harry Potter spin off movies?
Three words: canon inconsistencies. Rowling's retroactive lore changes frustrate book purists. Also, some feel Newt's story got overshadowed by Dumbledore/Grindelwald.
Should I watch Harry Potter spin off movies before the original series?
Godric's Hollow, no! Fantastic Beasts contains major spoilers for Dumbledore's backstory. Always watch release order: HP 1-7 → Fantastic Beasts.
Which Harry Potter spin off movie has the best creatures?
First one, hands down. The occamy, demiguise, and niffler sequences are peak magic. Later films prioritized human drama over beasts.
Final Thoughts
Are Harry Potter spin off movies as perfect as the originals? Probably not. But they offer new corners of the wizarding world to explore when you've worn out your Deathly Hallows disc. The key is adjusting expectations – they're different beasts (pun intended).
I'll keep watching them, flaws and all. Why? Because that moment when Newt first walks into MACUSA or Dumbledore casts patronus fireflies... it still gives me chills. That's the Potter magic we crave.
My advice? Watch the first Fantastic Beasts with butterbeer (homemade recipe: cream soda + butterscotch syrup + whipped cream). Lower your guard. You might rediscover the wonder.
Comment