So you're sick of running out of hot water mid-shower or staring at that bulky tank hogging space? You're not alone. Last winter during that nasty cold snap, my 15-year-old Rheem started leaking all over the garage floor. That's when I seriously looked into how to replace water heater with tankless models. Let me walk you through everything – the good, the bad, and what nobody tells you.
Why Ditch the Tank? The Real Benefits of Going Tankless
First off, forget those endless lectures about "energy efficiency." Here's what actually matters in daily life. Tankless units heat water on demand using either gas burners or electric coils. No more storing 40+ gallons of lukewarm water 24/7. My gas bill dropped nearly 30% after replacing water heater with tankless – around $25 monthly savings in a 3-bedroom house.
| Aspect | Traditional Tank Heater | Tankless Water Heater |
|---|---|---|
| Space Needed | 16+ sq ft floor space | Mounts on wall (2 sq ft) |
| Hot Water Supply | Limited by tank size | Endless (if sized right) |
| Avg Lifespan | 8-12 years | 15-20 years |
| Energy Cost (Annual) | $400-$600 | $200-$350 |
But it's not perfect. That upfront cost? Ouch. Expect $1,200-$3,500 just for the unit before installation. And if you've got old wiring or gas lines? Upgrading can add another grand. I remember getting quotes and nearly choked when one plumber said $6k total for a whole-home gas unit.
Personal insight: The "endless shower" dream is real – until someone flushes a toilet. Tankless systems have flow limits. My first unit couldn't handle two showers running at once. Learned that the hard way when my kid screamed during shampoo rinse.
Is Tankless Right For You? Let's Cut Through the Hype
Before you commit to replacing water heater with tankless, answer these questions:
- What fuels your home? Gas units need proper venting (stainless steel pipes ain't cheap). Electric needs heavy-duty circuits (often 200+ amps total service)
- How many hot water spots run simultaneously? Count showers, dishwashers, washing machines running at peak times
- What's your groundwater temperature? Colder regions need more powerful units (check EPA regional charts)
Top Brands Breakdown – From My Garage to Yours
After testing three brands during my renovation phase, here's the real scoop:
| Brand | Model | Best For | Price Range | GPM (Flow Rate) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Rinnai | RL94iN (Natural Gas) | Large homes (4+ bathrooms) | $1,500-$1,800 | 9.4 GPM |
| EcoSmart | ECO 36 (Electric) | Moderate climates / smaller homes | $600-$750 | 4.2 GPM |
| Navien | NPE-A2 (Condensing) | High efficiency seekers | $1,700-$2,100 | 10.2 GPM |
Surprised Navien costs more? Their built-in recirculation pumps eliminate cold water sandwich effect – worth every penny if you hate waiting.
Regret alert: I initially bought a cheap electric unit for my basement apartment. Bad move. Winter groundwater at 48°F meant lukewarm showers when flow exceeded 2 GPM. Had to upgrade within a year.
The Actual Process: Replacing Water Heater with Tankless Step-by-Step
Thinking about DIY? Unless you're licensed for gas/electrical work, don't. But understanding the process helps avoid getting ripped off.
Installation Reality Check
Professional install involves:
- Removing old tank (disposal fees apply)
- Upgrading gas lines to ¾" diameter (most tanks use ½")
- Installing proper venting (stainless steel is standard)
- Electrical upgrades if going electric (dedicated 40-50 amp breakers)
- Mounting unit and connecting plumbing
Expect 6-10 hours labor ($800-$2,000). My plumber charged $1,200 for a straightforward gas conversion.
Money saver: Ask about local utility rebates. Got $400 back from my gas company for installing an Energy Star unit. Some states add tax credits too.
Maintenance: The Unsexy Truth About Owning Tankless
Nobody mentions this at purchase. Mineral buildup will murder your unit without annual flushing. Here's my maintenance kit essentials:
- Submersible pump ($50)
- 5-gallon bucket
- White vinegar (3-4 gallons)
- Service valves (install during initial setup!)
Flushing takes 45 minutes. Skip it? Expect $500 repair bills when heat exchangers clog. Learned that lesson the expensive way.
Your Top Tankless Replacement Questions – Answered Honestly
Can tankless heaters handle whole houses?
Yes, if properly sized. Calculate your peak GPM demand:
- Shower: 1.5-2.5 GPM (low-flow vs. standard)
- Dishwasher: 1.5 GPM
- Kitchen faucet: 1.0 GPM
Two showers + dishwasher = 5.5 GPM minimum needed. Buy a unit exceeding this by 20%.
Do tankless water heaters work during power outages?
Gas models need electricity for controls/ignition. No power? No hot water. Keep a camping shower as backup.
Is the "cold water sandwich" real?
Annoyingly yes. When you briefly turn off faucet then back on, leftover cold water in pipes hits first. Point-of-use units under sinks solve this best.
Cost Analysis: Will You Actually Save Money?
Let's break down real numbers for switching to tankless:
| Expense | Tank Heater | Tankless Heater |
|---|---|---|
| Unit Cost | $800-$1,500 | $1,000-$3,000+ |
| Installation | $500-$900 | $800-$2,500 |
| Annual Energy | $450 | $250 |
| 10-Year Total | $5,300 | $4,500 |
Key takeaway: You'll save long-term but need 5+ years to break even. Worth it if staying put.
The Bottom Line: Should YOU Replace Water Heater with Tankless?
After living with tankless for four years? Absolutely – but only if:
- You've got space constraints (garages, closets)
- Your household fights over hot water
- You'll stay in the home 7+ years
- Budget allows $3k+ for proper installation
Still hesitating? Consider hybrid options like heat pump water heaters. They're cheaper to run than tanks but bulkier than tankless. Whatever you choose, get three quotes minimum. That rookie mistake cost me $800.
Got questions I didn't cover? Drop them in the comments. I respond personally – no bots here.
Comment