Remember the 2018 Oscar season? Man, that was a wild ride. I stayed up way too late watching screeners and arguing with friends about which film deserved Best Picture. If you're digging into the best picture Oscar nominations 2018 today – maybe you're a film student or just reliving that awards season – let's unpack what made these nine films stand out. No fluff, just the real talk you won't find on generic listicles.
The Complete 2018 Best Picture Nominees List
First things first, here are all nine contenders that fought for the top prize that year. Honestly, it felt stronger than some recent years – fewer filler nominees, more genuine heavyweights.
| Movie Title | Director | Key Actors | Box Office (Global) | Why It Stood Out |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| The Shape of Water | Guillermo del Toro | Sally Hawkins, Michael Shannon | $195 million | Genre-bending fantasy romance |
| Three Billboards Outside Ebbing, Missouri | Martin McDonagh | Frances McDormand, Sam Rockwell | $160 million | Raw exploration of grief and justice |
| Dunkirk | Christopher Nolan | Fionn Whitehead, Tom Hardy | $527 million | Immersive wartime experience |
| Get Out | Jordan Peele | Daniel Kaluuya, Allison Williams | $255 million | Social horror with razor-sharp satire |
| Lady Bird | Greta Gerwig | Saoirse Ronan, Laurie Metcalf | $79 million | Authentic coming-of-age storytelling |
| Phantom Thread | Paul Thomas Anderson | Daniel Day-Lewis, Lesley Manville | $47 million | Hypnotic character study |
| The Post | Steven Spielberg | Meryl Streep, Tom Hanks | $179 million | Timely political journalism drama |
| Call Me by Your Name | Luca Guadagnino | Timothée Chalamet, Armie Hammer | $42 million | Sensual summer romance |
| Darkest Hour | Joe Wright | Gary Oldman, Kristin Scott Thomas | $150 million | Oldman's transformative Churchill |
Fun fact: This was the last year with a variable number of Best Picture nominees (between 5-10). After 2018, they fixed it at 10.
What Really Defined the 2018 Oscar Contenders?
Looking back, the best picture Oscar nominations 2018 weren't just great films – they reflected Hollywood's evolving identity. Diversity finally started feeling less like tokenism and more organic. Four of the nine directors were first-time Best Picture nominees, and three nominees centered on female protagonists (a big deal back then).
The Cultural Impact
- Get Out redefined horror as Oscar-worthy social commentary
- Lady Bird proved female-directed coming-of-age stories could be universal
- Call Me by Your Name brought LGBTQ+ romance to mainstream awards
I recall heated debates about whether Three Billboards glorified police brutality redemption – a conversation that foreshadowed today's discourse.
The Box Office vs. Prestige Divide
Notice how Dunkirk grossed over half a billion dollars while Phantom Thread barely made $47 million? Yet both got best picture Oscar nominations 2018. Shows how the Academy balanced commercial hits with arthouse darlings. Smart move, honestly.
Deep Dive on Key Nominees and Why They Mattered
Let's get beyond the Wikipedia summaries. Having rewatched most of these recently, here's what holds up – and what doesn't.
The Shape of Water: More Than Just a Fish Romance
Guillermo del Toro's win wasn't just about practical effects (though Doug Jones in that suit was incredible). It celebrated outsiders – a mute cleaner, a gay neighbor, a black coworker. Still, some critics argued it borrowed too heavily from 1954's Creature from the Black Lagoon. Valid point? Maybe, but del Toro made it his own.
Three Billboards: McDonagh's Masterpiece or Problematic?
Frances McDormand's performance? Flawless. Sam Rockwell's racist cop redemption arc? That's where it gets thorny in 2024 hindsight. I loved it in theaters, but rewatching last year, certain scenes aged poorly. Yet its exploration of rage remains potent.
Get Out – The Game Changer
Jordan Peele did the unthinkable: made a horror film that became a cultural reset. Remember the "sunken place" memes? What gets overlooked is its precise screenplay structure – every line matters. Worth studying if you're into screenwriting.
| Film | Production Budget | Global Box Office | Profit Margin | Oscar Wins |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Get Out | $4.5 million | $255 million | 5,566% | Best Original Screenplay |
| Dunkirk | $100 million | $527 million | 427% | 3 technical awards |
| Lady Bird | $10 million | $79 million | 690% | 0 (snubbed!) |
| Phantom Thread | $35 million | $47 million | 34% | Best Costume Design |
Source: Box Office Mojo data compiled 2018. Get Out remains one of history's most profitable horror films.
Major Snubs That Still Hurt
No best picture Oscar nominations 2018 discussion is complete without mentioning who got robbed. These omissions sparked outrage:
- Wonder Woman (Patty Jenkins) – First female-led superhero hit, groundbreaking director
- The Florida Project (Sean Baker) – Gritty child's-eye-view of poverty
- Blade Runner 2049 (Denis Villeneuve) – Visual masterpiece that bombed financially
I saw Blade Runner 2049 in IMAX twice – Roger Deakins' cinematography alone deserved a nod. But hey, the Academy rarely rewards sci-fi unless it's Gravity or Dune.
Frequently Asked Questions About the 2018 Oscar Race
Based on what people actually search about best picture Oscar nominations 2018:
Why did The Shape of Water win over Three Billboards?
Three Billboards swept the Globes and BAFTAs, making it the frontrunner. But Shape of Water had guild support (PGA, DGA). Ultimately, del Toro's passion project resonated with preferential ballots – voters ranked it consistently higher.
Was Get Out seriously considered for Best Picture?
Absolutely. It won Original Screenplay and had strong Best Picture backing. Horror bias likely cost it the top prize. Jordan Peele himself admitted surprise at the nomination: "I never thought a movie about racism would connect like this."
Why only nine nominees instead of ten?
The Academy used a complex vote-transfer system. Films needed #1 votes from at least 5% of voters. In 2018, only nine cleared that threshold.
Did any studio campaign unusually hard?
Fox Searchlight pushed Three Billboards aggressively with "For Your Consideration" screenings starting August 2017 – extremely early. Meanwhile, Phantom Thread had a quiet December release but benefited from Daniel Day-Lewis' "final performance" narrative.
Where to Stream These Films in 2024
Practical info you'll need:
| Film | Subscription Streaming | Rental/Purchase | Free Option |
|---|---|---|---|
| The Shape of Water | Hulu | Amazon Prime ($3.99) | Kanopy (library card) |
| Get Out | Netflix | YouTube ($2.99) | Pluto TV (with ads) |
| Lady Bird | Netflix | Apple TV ($4.99) | Hoopla (library) |
| Dunkirk | Max | Vudu ($3.99) | – |
| Call Me by Your Name | Netflix | Google Play ($4.99) | Kanopy |
Pro tip: Use JustWatch.com to track real-time availability.
My Personal Takeaways Revisiting These Films
Watching them six years later reveals surprises:
- Holds Up Best: Get Out feels even more relevant. Lady Bird's mother-daughter tension remains perfect.
- Most Overrated: Darkest Hour. Gary Oldman's prosthetic Oscar™ was deserved, but the film's glorification of Churchill ignores problematic history.
- Underrated Gem: Phantom Thread. Initially dismissed as "too cold," its toxic romance and costume details reward rewatches.
- Biggest Missed Opportunity: The Post. Streep and Hanks + Spielberg should've been electric. Instead? Like a dry history lesson.
What stays with me is how these best picture Oscar nominations 2018 pushed boundaries. They proved genre films (Get Out), intimate indies (Lady Bird), and non-traditional romances (Call Me by Your Name) belonged in the Best Picture conversation. The ripple effects are still felt today – just look at Everything Everywhere All at Once's sweep years later.
Anyway, if you're diving into this for a project or just nostalgia, start with Get Out and Lady Bird. They capture that 2018 lightning in a bottle best. And if anyone tells you The Shape of Water didn't deserve it? Show them the fish-man dance sequence. Pure cinema.
Comment