Remember walking into English class on syllabus day and seeing that reading list? Some kids groaned, a few nerds (like me) got secretly excited, but everyone wondered: Why do we have to read these exact books? After teaching high school English for 11 years, I've seen every reaction to required reading. Let's cut through the academic fluff and talk honestly about books read in high school – what actually matters, which ones are worth your time, and how to not lose your mind when faced with Dickens' page-long sentences.
Why These Specific Books Get Assigned (It's Not Just Torture)
Schools don't pick classics randomly. There's method behind the madness – though I'll admit some choices feel outdated. Having served on curriculum committees, I'll spill the tea. Books read in high school aim to:
- Introduce universal themes (love, power, identity) through diverse lenses
- Build cultural literacy for college discussions
- Develop critical analysis muscles – spotting symbols isn't just for English class
- Expose you to varied writing styles before college papers hit
That said, some books overstay their welcome. I once taught The Scarlet Letter to dead-eyed sophomores and thought, "There's gotta be better options now."
Teacher Confession: We know Lord of the Flies makes you wanna flip desks. But when a kid connects it to reality TV group dynamics? That's why it stays.
Most Common Books on High School Reading Lists (Like It or Not)
| Book Title | Why It's Taught | Student Complaints | Secret Perks |
|---|---|---|---|
| To Kill a Mockingbird | Racism, morality, perspective | "Court scenes drag on" | Atticus Finch = ultimate dad goals |
| Romeo and Juliet | Foundational literary techniques | "Old English is confusing" | Memes. So many memes. |
| The Great Gatsby | American Dream critique | "Rich people problems = boring" | Party scenes = relatable social commentary |
| 1984 | Government power, surveillance | "Depressing AF" | Makes TikTok algorithms creepier |
Notice how dystopian novels exploded after 2016? Curriculum reacts to the world. When I started teaching, The Hunger Games was considered "pop fiction." Now it's legit assigned reading – same with The Hate U Give.
Modern Books Replacing Classics (Finally)
Good news: reading lists aren't frozen in 1955. Schools increasingly swap problematic or irrelevant texts with fresh options tackling modern issues. Here's what's trending:
| Old Book Phasing Out | Modern Replacement | Why the Change |
|---|---|---|
| The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn | March (Graphic Novel Trilogy) | Authentic civil rights perspective without racial slurs |
| Catcher in the Rye | The Perks of Being a Wallflower | Better mental health rep, less whiny protagonist |
| Lord of the Flies | Station Eleven | Post-apocalyptic survival with actual character development |
My district swapped Great Expectations for Long Way Down (Jason Reynolds) last year. Kids who never finished assignments suddenly read ahead. That's the power of relevant books read in high school.
Overrated vs. Underrated High School Reads
Let's get controversial based on my classroom trenches:
- Underrated Gem: Fahrenheit 451 – More relevant now with book bans than in 1953
- Overrated Classic: The Old Man and the Sea – Sorry Hemingway fans, it's just fish struggle porn
- Underrated Gem: Their Eyes Were Watching God – Love story with poetic writing that slaps
- Overrated Classic: Wuthering Heights – Toxic relationships glorified as "romance"
Hacks for Surviving Tough Books
Staring down 300 pages of Moby Dick? Try these teacher-approved tricks:
When the Reading Feels Like Climbing Everest
- SparkNotes isn't cheating – IF you read the actual book too. Use summaries to grasp confusing plots
- Movie adaptations first – Controversial but effective for complex works like Shakespeare. Understand the story, then analyze text
- Find modern parallels – Gatsby's obsession with status = Instagram influencers. Suddenly it clicks
Sophomore year, I faked reading Heart of Darkness until the river metaphor discussion exposed me. Learned my lesson: audiobooks while walking count as "reading" and help focus.
Annotation That Doesn't Suck
Forget coloring entire pages yellow. Try:
- Circle repeated words (colors, objects = probably symbols)
- Write ONE word reactions in margins ("ugh" "lol" "wtf?")
- Draw arrows connecting character arguments
I grade hundreds of annotated books. The best? A kid drew zombies chasing characters in Pride and Prejudice. Unconventional? Yes. Showed he understood social pressures? Absolutely.
Why This Stuff Actually Matters Later
"When will I ever use this?" Valid question. Beyond college prep, books read in high school give you:
- BS detection skills: Analyzing political speeches? Same tools you used on Antony's funeral oration
- Empathy gym: Walking in Scout's or Elie Wiesel's shoes builds real-world perspective
- Conversation currency: References in movies, jobs, first dates (Pride and Prejudice came up on mine!)
A former student messaged me: "Had to explain dramatic irony in a marketing meeting – used Romeo and Juliet as an example. Coworkers were impressed."
Parents: How to Help Without Doing the Work
Seeing your kid suffer through Crime and Punishment? Do:
- Ask "What pissed you off today?" instead of "How was reading?"
- Watch film versions together and debate changes
- Share if you hated/loved it in high school – makes it human
Don't:
- Write their papers (we know)
- Trash the book – undermines the teacher
- Say "I never read it" like a flex
Frequently Asked Questions
Why do schools assign books with racism/sexism?
Tricky one. Books like Huck Finn show historical prejudice to critique it – but can backfire. Many schools now pair them with modern counter-narratives. Still messy.
Can I refuse to read something for religious reasons?
Usually yes. Districts have opt-out policies – but you'll likely need to read an alternative book. Talk to your librarian.
Do colleges care what books I read?
Not specifically. But they care about your analysis skills. A deep essay about one book beats skimming ten.
Why so many dead white guys?
Legacy systems change slow. But diversity stats are improving: 40% of assigned books now feature POC authors vs. 15% in 1990 (NCTE data).
What if I just SparkNote everything?
You might pass, but you lose the critical thinking workout. Like only watching highlight reels instead of playing sports.
The Bottom Line
Books read in high school form a shared cultural toolkit. Are all choices perfect? Nope. Is forcing disinterested teens through Silas Marner effective? Debatable. But when a kid tells me Night changed how they see injustice, or quotes Tennyson unironically? That's the magic. Approach them with curiosity – and a good audiobook backup.
What was YOUR most hated or loved required read? Shoot me an email – I collect these stories for curriculum meetings. Change starts with honest feedback.
Comment