Remember that Budweiser Clydesdale commercial during the 2013 Super Bowl? I was at Jake's sports bar when it aired. Half the place went silent, someone actually sniffled into their beer. That's the power of a truly great Super Bowl ad. It sticks with you.
Finding the absolute best Super Bowl commercials isn't just about laughs or star power. It's about cultural impact. That moment when 100 million people collectively gasp, laugh, or reach for tissues. When Apple's "1984" spot aired, my uncle (a tech skeptic) called it "mind-bending." He bought a Macintosh the next month.
What Separates Good from Legendary?
Let's be honest. Most Super Bowl ads vanish from memory faster than stadium nachos. But the best ones? They become part of pop culture vocabulary. Three things elevate them:
Emotional Gut-Punch: Like Google's "Loretta" (2020) about an elderly man using Google Assistant to preserve memories of his late wife. Watched it with my grandparents. Big mistake. We needed tissues.
Risk-Taking Creativity: Remember Old Spice's "The Man Your Man Could Smell Like" (2010)? Ridiculous. Brilliant. Sales jumped 107%.
Perfect Timing: Chrysler's "Imported from Detroit" (2011) aired during the auto industry bailout. Chills.
Funny how some brands spend $7 million for a dud. Remember that confusing cryptocurrency ad from last year? Yeah, neither does anyone else. That's why picking the true best Super Bowl commercials requires looking beyond the hype.
The Undisputed Heavyweight Champions
Forget subjective rankings. Based on sales impact, social media explosions, and Nielsen ratings, these are the titans.
Top 5 Highest Impact Ads of All Time
| Brand | Ad Title | Year | Result | Why It Worked |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Apple | "1984" | 1984 | Mac sales doubled | Dystopian visuals broke every advertising rule |
| Budweiser | "Puppy Love" | 2014 | 58 million YouTube views | Clydesdales + puppies = emotional atomic bomb |
| Old Spice | "The Man Your Man Could Smell Like" | 2010 | 107% sales increase | Absurd humor that went viral pre-TikTok |
| Doritos | "Crash the Super Bowl" winners | Various | Consistent top rankings | User-generated chaos (R.I.P. this program) |
| NFL | "100 Year Game" | 2019 | Highest-rated ad that year | Pure nostalgia with iconic players |
Apple's "1984" director Ridley Scott practically invented the Super Bowl ad as event television. The commercial only ran once. Yet 40 years later, marketing nerds still dissect it. Meanwhile, Doritos proved crowd-sourced ads could compete with Hollywood budgets. Their "Crash the Super Bowl" contest produced gems like 2016's ultrasound rivalry ad. Shame they discontinued it.
Personal Hot Take: While everyone raves about the 2022 Coinbase QR code bounce ad, I thought it was lazy. Cool effect? Sure. Memorable brand message? Nope.
Underrated Gems You Might've Forgotten
Not every best Super Bowl commercial gets the love it deserves. These slipped under the radar:
- Monster.com "When I Grow Up" (1999): Kids listing soul-crushing futures ("I wanna be a yes-man"). Darkly hilarious corporate satire.
- E-Trade "Singing Baby" (2000): Launched the talking baby trope. Annoying? Maybe. Effective? Stock surged 28%.
- Snickers "Betty White" (2010): Proved old-school celebrities could slay. Sales popped 15%.
That Snickers spot is personal favorite. They paid Betty White maybe $300k. Compare that to Cardi B's $10M+ tag today. Betty delivered ten times the punch.
Anatomy of a Perfect Super Bowl Spot
Why do these ads work when others tank? After watching every Super Bowl since 1996 (yes, I'm that guy), patterns emerge.
The 5-Second Rule
You've got five seconds to hook viewers before they check Twitter. See how these nailed it:
| Brand | Opening Shot | Hook |
|---|---|---|
| Toyota "How Great I Am" (2021) | Paralympian Jessica Long diving into a pool | Stunning visuals + Sia's cover |
| Amazon "Alexa Loses Her Voice" (2018) | Jeff Bezos glaring at malfunctioning Alexa | Star power + immediate conflict |
| Squarespace "Dream with Dolly" (2024) | Dolly Parton rewriting "Jolene" | Iconic music twist |
A buddy who directs Super Bowl spots told me they spend 80% of budgets on those first five seconds. "It's a $200,000 per second gamble," he said.
Strategic Cameo vs. Star Overload
Celebrity casting is a minefield. Compare successes and misfires:
- Win: Michael B. Jordan for Amazon Prime (2021). Smooth transitions between scenes made him integral to the story.
- Fail: 2022's car insurance ad cramming 6 celebs into 30 seconds. Felt like a desperate reunion show.
My rule? If the celebrity becomes the joke (like Larry David for Crypto.com rejecting crypto), it works. If they're just wallpaper (most car ads), waste of money.
2024's Standouts & What They Got Right
This year's ads proved humor still reigns supreme. Here's what separated winners from duds:
| Brand | Ad Concept | Reception | Why It Landed |
|---|---|---|---|
| Dunkin' | Ben Affleck working drive-thru | Most shared ad | Self-deprecating celebrity humor |
| NERDS | Anthony Anderson's mom obsessed with candy | Top-rated on USA Today | Relatable family dynamics |
| Verizon | Beyoncé breaking the internet | Massive social buzz | Tied to album drop (genius synergy) |
| Bud Light | Post Malone delivering beer | Mixed reviews | Safe but forgettable comeback attempt |
Notice how Dunkin' leveraged Affleck's real-life Boston roots and viral paparazzi shots of him working counters? Authenticity wins. Meanwhile, Bud Light's safe play after last year's controversy felt calculated. Not terrible, not great. Middle of the pack.
Controversial Calls: Ads Everyone Debates
Not all "best" lists agree. These sparked heated arguments:
Pepsi vs. Coke: The Eternal War
Coke's "Hey Kid, Catch!" (1979) remains iconic. But was Pepsi's "Apartment 10G" with Cindy Crawford (1992) sexist genius or cringe? I rewatched both:
- Coke: Pure joy. Mean Joe Greene tossing his jersey still gets me.
- Pepsi: Dated? Sure. But boosted sales 40% with teens. Can't argue results.
Personally? Coke wins on warmth. But Pepsi understood aspirational marketing before it had a name.
That Volkswagen Darth Vader Kid (2011)
Some call it manipulative. Others genius. A breakdown:
The Magic: Kid "using the Force" on Dad's Passat. Dad remotely starts car. Kid's awestruck face.
The Controversy: Purists argued it bastardized Star Wars. Sales jumped 23%.
My take? It worked because it nailed universal parenting moments. My cousin tried replicating it with his Honda. Epic fail. Still a top-tier best Super Bowl commercial.
Where to Find Full Ads & Behind-the-Scenes
YouTube's Super Bowl Ad playlist is cluttered with reaction videos. For pure archival gold:
- Ad Age's Vault: Searchable database since 1967. Found Apple's original "1984" storyboards there.
- SuperBowl-Ads.com: Clean interface with ratings stats. Their "Cost Per Second" calculator is terrifying.
- Brand YouTube Channels: Doritos releases director's cuts with commentary. Reveals why they cut that extra cheese shot.
Pro tip: Search "[Brand] + Super Bowl + Press Release" for strategy insights. Saw Microsoft's 2024 rationale: "Focus on accessibility tools, not flashy celebs." Explains their touching adaptive controller ad.
Creating Your Own Rankings
Hosting a viewing party? Skip generic bingo cards. Try this scoring system we use:
| Category | Max Points | Examples |
|---|---|---|
| Rewatchability | 5 | Would you voluntarily watch it tomorrow? (Budweiser Puppy Love: 5/5) |
| Brand Recall | 5 | Can you name the sponsor without logos? (Skechers 2024 with Mr. T: 2/5) |
| Emotional Impact | 5 | Laughter counts! (Kia's Robo Dog 2022: 4/5) |
| Risk Factor | 5 | Safe = 1, Boundary-pushing = 5 (Squarespace's Dolly Parton AI: 4/5) |
Last year's winner using our system was Workday's rockstar CFO ad. Silly? Yes. Unforgettable? Absolutely. Scored 18/20. Meanwhile, that luxury car ad with sweeping drone shots? Generic. 7/20.
Why Your Brain Remembers Certain Ads
Neuroscience explains why some commercials stick. Dr. Emily Sanders (cognitive researcher I interviewed) broke it down:
Peak-End Rule: Viewers judge ads by their emotional peak and final moment. Google's Loretta ended with empty wheelchair → tears.
Mirror Neurons: We physically feel what we see. Watching the Clydesdale nuzzle the puppy? Your brain releases oxytocin.
This explains why purely funny ads like Doritos' screaming goat rarely make "best ever" lists. No peak emotional moment. Whereas Apple's "1984" climax with the hammer throw? Iconic.
Super Bowl Ad FAQs Answered
What's the most expensive Super Bowl ad ever?
2024 spots hit $7.5M for 30 seconds. But adjusted for inflation? 2000's dot-com era ads were pricier. Pets.com paid $9.2M in today's dollars... then folded 9 months later. Ouch.
Do Super Bowl ads actually boost sales?
Mixed bag. Old Spice sales doubled. But for every winner, there's a Groupon Tibet fiasco (2011) that backfired spectacularly. Rule of thumb: If your ad trends for controversy instead of creativity, sales may dip.
Why do so many animal ads work?
Neurological hack. Princeton studies show puppy/kitten visuals increase viewer attention by 400% vs. human-focused ads. Budweiser's Clydesdales are basically cheating.
Has any ad run without approval?
One infamous case: In 2017, a Minnesota startup faked an approved QR code during broadcast. FCC fined them $2.3M. Not worth the stunt.
Who decides the "official" best ads?
No single authority. USA Today's Ad Meter uses viewer polls. Ad Age focuses on cultural impact. My advice? Watch the ads, ignore the hype lists, and trust your gut. If you're still talking about it Monday morning? That's a true best Super Bowl commercial.
Saw a stat once: 75% of Super Bowl viewers discuss ads more than the game. That number feels low based on my Super Bowl parties. Last year, we spent 20 minutes debating whether that crypto ad was satire or sincere. Never resolved it. But hey, that's the magic. When an ad fuels conversations for weeks beyond the broadcast? That's legendary status. That's what separates the expensive noise from the real best Super Bowl commercials of all time.
Comment